“East Coast Chaos: Mets Crumble, Yankees Struggle – Is NYC Baseball in Crisis?”

 

The Mets Are Crumbling, and the Yankees Aren’t Much Better | Deadspin.comJul 23, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; New York Yankees starting pitcher Max Fried (54) stands between third baseman Oswald Peraza (18, left) and shortstop Anthony Volpe (11) as he waits to be relieved in the sixth inning against the Toronto Blue Jays at Rogers Centre. Mandatory Credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images

 

The ever-optimistic Brandon Nimmo stood in the New York Mets’ locker room late Tuesday night and uttered eight words that were meant to reassure the fanbase.

Those same words, however, also could have applied to everyone fretting over the general state of baseball in the Big Apple.

“Things are not as bleak as they seem,” Nimmo said.

Two days later, things look much bleaker for the Mets — and they aren’t much better for the Yankees.

The Mets suffered their eighth loss in nine games Wednesday afternoon with a 4-1 setback to the Cleveland Guardians. New York also was nearly no-hit by Gavin Williams, who gave up a homer to Juan Soto with one out in the ninth inning.

The Mets are doing a bang-up job of making their 12 months as baseball’s best team look like a mirage.

They led the majors with 106 wins from June 12, 2024, through June 12, 2025, a span in which they made a Cinderella run to the National League Championship Series and seemed to completely change the vibes at Citi Field.

But the Mets are just 18-28 since June 13. The only teams with a worse record are the Colorado Rockies and Washington Nationals — not exactly the company contenders want to keep. The Mets have gone from leading the NL East by 5 1/2 games to the last wild-card spot, just three games ahead of the Cincinnati Reds.

There’s nothing fluky about the Mets’ tailspin. They rank last in the majors with 182 runs since June 13 and have given up 242 runs, the third most behind only — you guessed it — the Rockies and Nationals.

President of baseball operations David Stearns had a solid trade deadline in which he acquired relievers Gregory Soto, Ryan Helsley and Tyler Rogers. But he didn’t add a starting pitcher to a frayed rotation. David Peterson, the losing pitcher Wednesday, is the only starter to pitch six innings since June 7. Stearns had little choice but to hope lineup anchors Pete Alonso, Francisco Lindor, Nimmo and Soto would snap out of their slumps. Yet Lindor, Nimmo and Soto all have an OPS at least 40 points below their career marks, while Alonso — whose OPS of .859 is a shade better than his career mark of .855 — is batting .212 since June 13.

At least Stearns didn’t crow “mission accomplished” following the deadline. That unfortunate word selection in regard to improving his team belonged to Yankees general manager Brian Cashman, who continues to act nothing like the executive who apprenticed under Gene Michael and had to deal with George Steinbrenner’s fury on an hourly basis.

The Yankees, who made it to the World Series last year, were 42-25 through June 12 — the third-best record in the majors. But they are just 19-29 since and are clinging to the final wild-card spot in the American League.

As with Stearns’ moves, Cashman’s actions to bolster the bullpen at the deadline did little to address his team’s fundamental flaws — literally, in this case.

The core of the relentless dynasty teams was built by Michael, who drafted and/or oversaw the development of Derek Jeter, Andy Pettitte, Jorge Posada, Mariano Rivera and Bernie Williams. The Core Five (why doesn’t Williams get the love?) played crisply, capitalized on any little mistake by the opposition and thrived in the New York spotlight.

Now the Yankees are filled with questionable fits who make the mistakes that other teams capitalize on.

In the last eight days alone, Austin Wells, a homegrown player, forgot the number of outs in the ninth inning and Jazz Chisholm Jr. got doubled off first base on a pop-up to second.

The duo received the most milquetoast of public rebukes from Aaron Boone, Cashman’s handpicked selection who has managed more games without winning a World Series than any Yankees skipper in history. This is a long way from Steinbrenner unloading on prospects Jim Beattie, Ken Clay and Bobby Meacham and calling future Hall of Famer Dave Winfield “Mr. May.”

Last Friday, the Yankees squandered a six-run lead against the Miami Marlins and suffered a 13-12 loss when their three new relievers — Jake Bird, David Bednar and Camilo Doval — combined to give up nine runs in the final 2 1/3 innings. While Bird is already in Triple-A, Bednar recorded a five-out save Wednesday because Devin Williams, whose New York tenure started poorly in April, might have pitched himself out of the closer’s role again by giving up six runs over 3 2/3 innings in his last four outings.

All this hand-wringing aside, the expanded playoffs and baseball’s built-in unpredictability — the Mets reached the NLCS despite opening 25-35 last year — means Nimmo’s optimism might prove prescient for at least one New York team.

And if not? Then New Yorkers will get to focus their attention on football season and two teams whose bleakness knows no limit — the Giants and Jets.

Related Posts

BRONX BLOCKBUSTER BUZZ: A former MLB GM drops a thunderbolt prediction that the Yankees could ship Spencer Jones to Miami in a jaw-dropping push for a Cy Young ace, instantly turning the rumor mill into a five-alarm blaze. The idea sounds insane, perfect, and terrifying all at once—an all-in gamble that could redraw the AL landscape overnight. Now the entire baseball world is hanging on one question: will New York actually pull off the kind of trade that rewrites legacies..ll

New York could add a big starting pitching upgrade at the cost of Spencer Jones.

BRONX FUTURE SHIFT: The picture sharpens as a possible landing spot for Spencer Jones comes into focus right after fresh Yankees ace trade rumors shake up their long-term blueprint. The sudden clarity adds a dramatic twist to New York’s roster plans as the spotlight swings toward the rising star’s next chapter. So is this the direction they’re really heading?..ll

The Yankees have reportedly called the Marlins recently about Sandy Alcantara, which would represent a perfect Spencer Jones trade fit.

RIVALRY FIRESTORM: The tension erupts as Mets pitcher Devin Williams throws a bold social-media jab straight at Yankees fans, instantly igniting the New York baseball feud to a whole new level. The unexpected swipe sends shockwaves through both sides as the rivalry heats up ahead of the season. So what set off this explosive shot?..ll

Mets’ reliever Devin Williams recently took a slight jab at Yankees fans via a social media post that you must read.

BRONX SHOCKWAVE: A stunning twist hits the offseason as whispers grow louder that a Yankees trade for Fernando Tatis Jr. is “not impossible”, cracking open a door no one expected New York to even touch. The mere idea of a superstar shakeup sends the entire baseball world into overdrive as the Yankees size up what a move like this could mean for their future. So is this the blockbuster they’re actually lining up?..ll

The Athletic reports a Fernando Tatis Jr. trade to the Yankees isn’t impossible, opening the door for a potential blockbuster.

BRONX STORM ALERT: Tension spikes as the Yankees roll into the Winter Meetings with swirling rumors hinting at moves that could flip the entire AL picture overnight. Front-office chatter grows louder as New York circles potential shock additions that might redefine their offseason blueprint. So what bombshell are they cooking up?..ll

Three needs this week; closing the outfield gap; breaking down the Contemporary Era

METSWAVE BREAKOUT: The Mets lock in reliever Williams on a massive $51M, three-year deal, whispers erupt about how this move reshapes their late-game firepower, and now the entire league is watching to see what New York unleashes next..ll Read more 👇👇👇

Devin Williams and the Mets finalized a $51 million, three-year contract on Wednesday that locks in a critical late-inning reliever as New York rebuilds its bullpen this offseason.