4 bold roster moves the Yankees should make, but don’t have the guts to

Aug 5, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA;  New York Yankees relief pitcher Devin Williams (38) reacts after leaving the game during the eighth inning against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Field. Mandatory Credit: Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

The New York Yankees need a change. The team is in the midst of a prolonged struggle (20-40) that seems to have no end in sight, and with every misstep New York is getting closer and closer to losing their grip on the season completely.

Changes will come as the Yankees have several players on the injured list ramping up towards making returns to action, but that’s not the kind of change the team needs. Something more drastic needs to happen — something bold to really shake things up. In all reality, only one move won’t suffice.

The Yankees should look at players who survived the trade deadline, but are sure to be gone in the offseason, and consider whether or not a change needs to be made earlier. In other cases, they don’t need to show some pieces the door for good, but a clear message must be sent, and some seemingly safe players need a serious wake-up call.

Reliever Yerry De los Santos should stay on the roster over the likes of Jonathan Loaisiga and Mark Leiter Jr.

Yerry De los Santos just returned to the 26-man roster, but that doesn’t mean his reign will be long. As the Yankees prepare to welcome back Jonathan Loaisiga, there’s a chance they could option De los Santos to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in order to make room.

The peripherals don’t look great for the former Pittsburgh Pirate, but with a 1.63 ERA on the season, you can’t argue with the results. In that way, he’s much the opposite of Leiter Jr., who routinely underperforms his stellar peripherals. Not only that, De los Santos is capable of providing length out of the ‘pen in a way that Loaisiga and Leiter Jr. can’t be trusted to do.

Yes, Ryan Yarbrough should be back soon and is capable of handling a bulk role, but the Yankees should have a different plan for the veteran southpaw. Instead, De los Santos should remain in his role, and Loaisiga or Leiter Jr. should be shown the door whenever the time comes.

Starting pitcher Cam Schlittler should be sent down in favor of Ryan Yarbrough re-entering the starting rotation

As impressive as the rookie has been at times, dazzling fans with his high-octane fastball, the one thing that has become clear with Cam Schlittler is that he doesn’t always have full command of his arsenal. With a 5.03 BB/9 and a 2.29 HR/9, it’s clear that he misses his target far too often, both inside and outside of the strike zone.

With just 25 1/3 innings pitched at Triple-A, there’s a legitimate question as to whether or not the 24-year-old would benefit from some more seasoning at the minors’ highest level while the club determines whether sticking by him or re-inserting Ryan Yarbrough into the rotation when he comes off the IL gives it the best chance to win games down the stretch.

Catcher Austin Wells should give way to Ben Rice and J.C. Escarra behind the plate

Austin Wells has never found his groove this season, but his latest struggles have made his presence in the lineup completely untenable. The young catcher has been an automatic out since the All-Star break with a putrid .334 OPS in the second half that simply can’t continue.

Meanwhile, every game that Wells starts behind the dish means that the team is leaving one of its better bats on the bench as it struggles to find playing time for both Ben Rice and Paul Goldschmidt. Perhaps the best way to proceed forward would be to make Rice the primary catcher and recall J.C. Escarra to handle backup duties. That would either send Wells to Triple-A or perhaps even to the IL to address his strange medical issue.

Reliever Devin Williams should be given his walking papers now rather than later

As an impending free agent, there is simply no way that Devin Williams is anything but one-and-done in the Bronx. After a run as one of the most dominant closers in baseball, Williams hasn’t looked the same since surrendering a season-ending three-run homer to Pete Alonso in last year’s playoffs.

Outside of a 0.93 ERA in June, Williams has been an unmitigated disaster and might be pitching worse now than he did at the height of his early-season struggles. Over 8 2/3 second-half innings, he’s posted an eye-popping 10.38 ERA and allowed a terrifying .703 slugging percentage.

This might be a longshot given his pedigree, but there’s a chance the Yankees decided they can take no more and put the former All-Star on waivers. If that were to happen, it would signal that the club believes the righty is beyond repair, and no amount of role changes or other coddling will be able to bring about a return to form. This would be admitting defeat, something the Yankees hate to do, but after his latest blowup, it might be necessary.

Related Posts

BRONX BLOCKBUSTER BUZZ: A former MLB GM drops a thunderbolt prediction that the Yankees could ship Spencer Jones to Miami in a jaw-dropping push for a Cy Young ace, instantly turning the rumor mill into a five-alarm blaze. The idea sounds insane, perfect, and terrifying all at once—an all-in gamble that could redraw the AL landscape overnight. Now the entire baseball world is hanging on one question: will New York actually pull off the kind of trade that rewrites legacies..ll

New York could add a big starting pitching upgrade at the cost of Spencer Jones.

BRONX FUTURE SHIFT: The picture sharpens as a possible landing spot for Spencer Jones comes into focus right after fresh Yankees ace trade rumors shake up their long-term blueprint. The sudden clarity adds a dramatic twist to New York’s roster plans as the spotlight swings toward the rising star’s next chapter. So is this the direction they’re really heading?..ll

The Yankees have reportedly called the Marlins recently about Sandy Alcantara, which would represent a perfect Spencer Jones trade fit.

RIVALRY FIRESTORM: The tension erupts as Mets pitcher Devin Williams throws a bold social-media jab straight at Yankees fans, instantly igniting the New York baseball feud to a whole new level. The unexpected swipe sends shockwaves through both sides as the rivalry heats up ahead of the season. So what set off this explosive shot?..ll

Mets’ reliever Devin Williams recently took a slight jab at Yankees fans via a social media post that you must read.

BRONX SHOCKWAVE: A stunning twist hits the offseason as whispers grow louder that a Yankees trade for Fernando Tatis Jr. is “not impossible”, cracking open a door no one expected New York to even touch. The mere idea of a superstar shakeup sends the entire baseball world into overdrive as the Yankees size up what a move like this could mean for their future. So is this the blockbuster they’re actually lining up?..ll

The Athletic reports a Fernando Tatis Jr. trade to the Yankees isn’t impossible, opening the door for a potential blockbuster.

BRONX STORM ALERT: Tension spikes as the Yankees roll into the Winter Meetings with swirling rumors hinting at moves that could flip the entire AL picture overnight. Front-office chatter grows louder as New York circles potential shock additions that might redefine their offseason blueprint. So what bombshell are they cooking up?..ll

Three needs this week; closing the outfield gap; breaking down the Contemporary Era

METSWAVE BREAKOUT: The Mets lock in reliever Williams on a massive $51M, three-year deal, whispers erupt about how this move reshapes their late-game firepower, and now the entire league is watching to see what New York unleashes next..ll Read more 👇👇👇

Devin Williams and the Mets finalized a $51 million, three-year contract on Wednesday that locks in a critical late-inning reliever as New York rebuilds its bullpen this offseason.