Yankees must find a way to ditch this overpaid pitcher as his trade value increases

San Francisco Giants v New York Yankees

With the likes of Ryan Yarbrough and Will Warren filling out the back of the New York Yankees rotation, it may seem odd to suggest that the team should do everything in it’s power ship out a veteran starter like Marcus Stroman, but that’s exactly what would be in the best interests of the club.

Stroman has only pitched 9.1 innings over three starts since going down in mid-April with a knee injury. Now, he’s on the verge of a return after some setbacks, facing live hitters this past Saturday for the first time since May 9. While the Yankees could still use an addition in the rotation, they’ve figured out how to get by in his absence.

Clarke Schmidt’s return has helped stabilize things, while Ryan Yarbrough has been outstanding since being inserted into the rotation. There’s a question as to how long the soft-tossing southpaw can keep it up, but even if he should turn into a pumpkin, the Yankees will eventually have last year’s AL Rookie of the Year, Luis Gil, returning to replace him.

The question then becomes whether or not Stroman can be an upgrade over Will Warren, who has shown flashes of brilliance while also putting up duds like his May 31 outing against the Dodgers, when he got shelled to the tune of six hits, four walks, and seven earned runs allowed in just 1.1 innings of work.

Still, if the Yankees are going to roll with an inconsistent right-hander to round out their rotation, better the 26-year-old Warren, who at least brings upside over the 34-year-old Stroman.

That brings us to what shedding Stroman’s salary can do for the team, and why, as a whole, the club would be better off without him.

The Yankees can take advantage of a weak starting pitching market – while freeing up funds to solve their biggest need – by trading Marcus Stroman.

Despite his poor performance in a small sample and lengthy IL stint, Stroman’s trade value has only increased over the last several weeks now that his pesky vesting option is off the table. It will be impossible for him to reach the necessary 140-inning threshold; therefore, whichever team acquires him will be looking at a half-season rental rather than the possibility of being saddled with him for an $18 million price tag in 2026.

As of now, contenders with needs in the rotation don’t seem to have many places to turn. The presumed prize of the trade deadline, 2022 NL Cy Young winner Sandy Alcantara, has fallen flat with a 7.89 ERA in his return from Tommy John surgery.

The next best available name might be the Angels’ Tyler Anderson, a 35-year-old soft-tossing southpaw who may best be described as a deluxe version of Ryan Yarbrough. The rest of the sellers like the White Sox and Pirates will likely pefer to hold on to their young pitching talent.

Stroman, based on his previous track record, might represent the best available right-handed starting option, alongside Arizona’s Zach Gallen and Merril Kelly should the Diamondbacks accept their fate as sellers at the deadline.

That could mean a nice little return for the Yankees for a pitcher who still likely has no place on the team. More importantly, the Yankees’ steely determination to stay under the so-called “Steve Cohen” luxury tax threshold means the club can’t take on very much money in trades without something substantial going back out.

Clearing out the rest of Stroman’s $18 million salary will give them the wiggle room to chase the best available second baseman rather than relying on bargain-basement options.

In turn, that will make the Yankees a more complete team overall, better positioned to make a deep October run that hopefully ends in a more glorious fashion than 2024’s version.

Related Posts

🔥QUEENS SHOCKWAVE: Steven Cohen finally broke his silence on Francisco Lindor’s future with the Mets—and his words set the internet on fire. The message was cryptic, part confidence, part warning, leaving everyone guessing what comes next. One statement, and suddenly the fate of a franchise feels up in the air..ll

In the ever-evolving world of professional baseball, decisions about player contracts and team rosters can ignite passionate discussions among fans and analysts alike. Recently, Steven Cohen, the billionaire owner of the New York Mets, made headlines with a candid revelation regarding the future of star shortstop Francisco Lindor. This announcement, framed as a “stay or go” moment, has sent shockwaves through the Mets fanbase and the broader baseball community, prompting intense speculation and debate. As the Mets navigate their path in the competitive Major League Baseball landscape, Cohen’s words have highlighted the complexities of player retention, team strategy, and fan expectations. This article delves deep into the details of this revelation, exploring its implications, the reactions it has elicited, and what it means for the New York Mets moving forward.

🔥QUEENS FIRESTORM: An insider just dropped the bomb—Mets are willing to trade Pete Alonso in a desperate push to fix their defense. The clubhouse is stunned, fans are fuming, and the front office is walking a tightrope between logic and loyalty. One bold move could reshape the entire future of Queens baseball..ll

The New York Mets have long been a powerhouse in Major League Baseball, captivating fans with their offensive prowess and star-studded lineups. However, beneath the surface of their thrilling games lies a persistent issue that has plagued the team for seasons: a glaring weakness in defense. As the Mets navigate the competitive landscape of the MLB, experts and insiders are increasingly vocal about the need for significant improvements in their defensive strategy. This article delves deep into why the Mets are prioritizing defense enhancements, exploring the controversial decision to consider trading star first baseman Pete Alonso, and the backlash from passionate Mets fans. By examining insider insights, player performances, and fan sentiments, we uncover the motivations behind this bold move and its potential impact on the team’s future.

🔥QUEENS CRISIS CONTINUES: The Mets went through an entire 2025 season without solving their center field nightmare—and somehow made it worse. Rotations failed, depth vanished, and every “solution” turned into another headline of disappointment. Now the front office faces its biggest gamble yet—choosing the right free agent to stop the bleeding before 2026 begins..ll

The Mets got subpar production on both sides of the ball all year in center field in 2025

🔥DIAMOND SURPRISE: Luis Torrens just crashed the Gold Glove conversation, earning a finalist spot no one saw coming. His defense spoke louder than stats, turning quiet consistency into league-wide respect. Now the question hangs in the air—can the underdog finish the story with the trophy in hand?..ll

October 25, 2025 — Catcher Luis Torrens has officially been named a Gold Glove Award Finalist, recognizing him among the best defensive players in Major League Baseball…

🔥DIAMOND DISRUPTION: The Yankees and Astros are circling, and suddenly Jazz Chisholm’s future doesn’t look so certain. Whispers of trade “interest” have turned into full-blown speculation, shaking up front offices across the league. One bold move could flip his career—and the balance of power—overnight..ll

The New York Yankees and Houston Astros are both reportedly interested in a Brandon Lowe trade, so where does Jazz Chisholm Jr. go?

🔥BRONX BLUEPRINT: The Yankees are already eyeing 2026, and the hunt for outfield firepower is heating up. Big names, breakout bets, and one shocking dark horse are all in the mix. This offseason could redefine the pinstripes before a single pitch is thrown..ll

The Yankees outfield in 2026 could look different with Bellinger possibly out the door. What are the backup options?