MLB Rumors: Insider reveals potential cost of new Pete Alonso contract for New York Mets in 2026

Mets' Pete Alonso looks to continue torrid start in matchup vs. A's - Field Level Media - Professional sports content solutions | FLM

The New York Mets re-signed All-Star first baseman Pete Alonso in February, with owner Steve Cohen agreeing to a $54 million contract that would give the club the highest payroll in MLB. While Alonso has been an integral part of the Mets lineup this season, it seems increasingly likely to be a one-year pact.

Jon Heyman of the New York Post wrote that when Alonso exercises his opt-out clause this winter, he is likely to seek a multi-year extension worth at least $35 million per season. Thanks to MLB’s Competitive Balance Tax, that price would be closer to $40 million per season for New York. As a result, he isn’t expected back after this season.

Related: New York Mets could get huge revenue boost through potential MLB deal

  • Pete Alonso contract (Spotrac): $30 million salary in 2025, $24 million player option for 2026

Entering MLB games today, Alonso held the third-highest OPS with the second-most RBI (26) in baseball. He’s also among the league leaders in extra-base hits, including 11 doubles in 93 at-bats. It’s been an outstanding start coming off a season with a sub-.800 OPS for the first time in his career.

Related: New Juan Soto contract details, promise made by the New York Mets

  • Pete Alonso stats (ESPN): .333/.442/.667, 1.109 OPS, 26 RBI, 6 home runs, 11 doubles

Enjoying an outstanding contract year, in terms of production, Alonso has also been helped out by the Vladimir Guerrero Jr. contract extension. The Toronto Blue Jays signed their All-Star first baseman to a 14-year, $500 million contract extension worth $35.714 million annually.

Related: New York Mets game today, Mets schedule 2025

Heyman also noted that while Guerrero’s deal is worth $35.714 million annually, the length of the contract equates to a $40 million AAV for a short-term deal. As a result, Alonso could push to eclipse a $35 million average annual salary when he hits the open market, potentially seeking a deal that makes him the highest-paid first baseman in MLB in terms of contract average.

Related Posts

Mets set date for Frankie Montas debut after injury rehab

The New York Mets have been waiting all season for Frankie Montas to make his 2025 debut, but the wait is almost over.

Mets’ Rotation Could Get Lift With Return of Key Pitcher

Frankie Montas is expected to rejoin the Mets’ rotation on the upcoming homestand after missing significant time with a right lat strain.

Nolan McLean Deserves a Shot in Weakened Mets Rotation

This is where top pitching prospect Nolan McLean should come into play for the Mets, even though he likely will not.

Mets’ Blade Tidwell better in second career outing, but knows there’s more work to be done

Mets rookie Blade Tidwell fared better in his second career outing Friday night, but he knows the grind doesn’t stop here.

Yankees activate Luke Weaver from the IL, planning closer duties split with Devin Williams

The Yankees reinstated reliever Luke Weaver from the injured list on Friday afternoon, one day after hinting at the possibility of his return.

Yankees Mailbag: Managerial concerns and Winans’ immediate future

The mailbag is back after the roughest week of the season rocked the boat.