Red Sox Trade Idea Sends Alex Verdugo Deal Piece to Contender as Pitching Depth

The Boston Red Sox opened the season with three of their projected five starting pitchers on the injured list. Right-hander Brayan Bello is set to make his third rehab start on Friday as he works his way back from a shoulder injury and is projected to return later in April.

Veteran Lucas Gioloto was solid in a second rehab assignment on Wednesday but is expected to need at least two more. A third righty, Kutter Crawford, is still battling tendon pain in his right knee and is described as “a ways away” from his return.

Richard Fitts of the Boston Red Sox
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS – APRIL 07: Richard Fitts #80 of the Boston Red Sox pitches against the Toronto Blue Jays during the first inning at Fenway Park on April 07, 2025 in Boston, Massachusetts. Brian Fluharty/Getty Images

In the meantime, one of those rotation spots has been held down by 25-year-old Richard Fitts, a 2021 New York Yankees sixth-round pick who came to the Red Sox in the 2023-2024 offseason as part of the trade, along with receiver Greg Weissert, that sent controversial outfielder Alex Verdugo to the Bronx.

But when at least one of the Red Sox’s injured trio return, Fitts — who has allowed six runs in 12 innings over two starts this season — could be on the move again, as Boston looks to acquire more prospect depth, according to a trade proposal by MLB writer Jon Conahan of Athlon Sports.

Conahan identifies the Chicago Cubs, a team that in the offseason appeared to be going all-in to win the National League Central, as a likely destination for Fitts, should the Red Sox choose to trade him rather than option the Auburn product to Triple-A Worcester.

“The Cubs’ rotation is among the best in MLB, but it’s top-heavy and needs a right-handed arm, Conahan wrote. “Fitts isn’t exactly the perfect arm to fix their needs, but there aren’t many better options at this stage of the season than the Red Sox’ fourth starter.”

In exchange for Fitts, the Red Sox could look to add a prospect at the position that now most badly lacks depth in the Red Sox organization: catcher.

The Cubs could offer their No. 4 overall prospect Moises Ballesteros, a 21-year-old from Venezuela who was signed by the North Siders for a $1.2 million bonus in 2021, the second-highest amount out of all Cubs acquisitions in that year’s International class.

But Ballesteros would be a high price to pay.

For a pitcher of Fitts’ caliber — a mid-rotation starter at best — the Cubs would be more likely to serve up catcher Pablo Aliendo, a $200,000 signing in 2018 also out of Venezuela, who is currently at Double-A seven years later. Aliendo, 23, would be a development project for the Red Sox.

The Red Sox would likely require at least one more prospect, or significant cash considerations for Fitts if Aliendo was the best the Cubs could do at the backstop position.

Related Posts

REPORT: Dodgers Calling Up Top Prospect in Shocking Move Ahead of Trade Deadline

The Los Angeles Dodgers are calling up top prospect Alex Freeland, per The Athletic’s Fabian Ardaya. Freeland is the team’s No. 3 overall prospect, per MLB Pipeline, and plays…

Dodgers, in need of position player depth, to call up Alex Freeland, per reports

The Dodgers will call up one of their top prospects, infielder Alex Freeland, per a report from The Athletic, to help with their lack of depth of position players on the 40-man roster.

Dave Roberts teases further Dodgers IL stints before Alex Freeland call-up

Though the Dodgers secured a win over the Reds, Dave Roberts reveals that two Dodgers are in fear of landing on the injury list.

Mets, Yankees Have Shown Interest In Harrison Bader

The Twins are selling and Bader seems to be popular. Click over to MLB Trade Rumors to read more.

Mets’ Carlos Mendoza gets tossed from Padres game after Juan Soto outburst

New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza was ejected vs. Padres after defending Juan Soto during a heated strikeout outburst.

Drew Gilbert isn’t the only NY Mets prospect raising his trade value this July

Drew Gilbert’s July might be helping the New York Mets stir up trade talks, but he’s not the only outfielder putting scouts on alert. While Gilbert’s been showc