New York, NY – October 2025 — The future of slugger Pete Alonso with the New York Mets is once again under the microscope as MLB insider Connor Rogers weighed in on the All-Star’s pending free agency.
Speaking on SNY, Rogers suggested that Alonso’s chances of remaining with the Mets could depend heavily on his contract expectations — specifically, the length of the deal rather than the dollar amount.
“If Pete Alonso wants a 7-year deal, a 6-year deal, probably even a 5-year deal – I don’t think he’ll be back with the Mets,” said Rogers. “That’s my opinion. Not what they should or shouldn’t do, but what I think.”
Rogers went on to clarify that if Alonso’s market comes back around similar to last offseason — where shorter-term deals were being discussed — the door could still be open for a reunion.
“If this circles back similar to last season where it’s more in that 3-year deal market, then he has a good chance to be back with the Mets,” he added.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPppCfrRNB0
🔍 The Contract Question
Alonso, 30, has been one of the league’s premier power hitters since debuting in 2019, racking up multiple 40+ home run seasons and becoming a fan favorite at Citi Field. However, with new front office leadership under David Stearns, the Mets have been cautious about handing out long-term, high-value extensions to players nearing or past age 30.
The team’s roster construction suggests a focus on flexibility and younger talent — meaning a lengthy commitment to Alonso could clash with long-term strategy, even if his production remains elite.
💰 Market Value & Comparisons
League sources expect Alonso’s camp to seek a contract comparable to deals signed by top first basemen such as Freddie Freeman (6 years, $162M with the Dodgers) and Matt Olson (8 years, $168M with the Braves).
If Alonso indeed insists on a 6–7 year deal, Rogers’ comments imply that the Mets are unlikely to match those terms — potentially opening the door for big-market suitors like the Cubs, Giants, or Red Sox.
⚾ What’s Next?
As the offseason approaches, both sides are expected to maintain dialogue, but with no extension finalized during the 2024 season, Alonso’s path to free agency seems all but certain.
Whether the Mets choose to let him walk or re-engage with a shorter, high-AAV offer will likely define the early headlines of the 2025–26 offseason.
