The Los Angeles Lakers have built one of the most intriguing rosters in the league this offseason, but their potential 2025–26 rotation is already drawing skepticism.

On paper, the team’s projected starting lineup looks formidable: Luka Doncic running point, Austin Reaves at shooting guard, Rui Hachimura sliding into the small forward slot, LeBron James at power forward, and Deandre Ayton anchoring the middle.

The second unit features Gabe Vincent, Marcus Smart, Jake LaRavia, Jarred Vanderbilt, and Jaxson Hayes, while Bronny James, Dalton Knecht, Maxi Kleber, Adou Thiero, and the Lakers’ two-way players round out the depth chart.

Yet, as exciting as the star power looks, NBA fans aren’t convinced this rotation will work as smoothly as the front office hopes.

The biggest concern comes on the defensive end. Social media was quick to point out that a Doncic–Reaves backcourt could leave the Lakers vulnerable against elite guard play.

One fan joked, “lmao do we plan on allowing other teams to score 180 points w that starting lineup.” 

That critique echoes long-standing questions about Luka’s defensive commitment and Reaves’ struggles to contain quicker guards. While Ayton is a capable rim protector, he isn’t considered elite defensively, meaning the Lakers could be leaning heavily on LeBron and Rui to plug holes.

Others questioned the balance of the roster. Dalton Knecht, the Lakers’ 2024 lottery pick, is already viewed by many fans as one of the better scoring options on the team.

“Dalton Knecht is probably the 7th or 8th best player on the team when given the minutes,” one comment read, suggesting the rookie could end up forcing his way into a bigger role.

There’s also debate about Rui Hachimura’s fit in the starting five, with fans preferring Jarred Vanderbilt to bring defensive energy from the jump. 

“I prefer Vando starting and Rui off the bench,” wrote another fan, highlighting the need for more balance between offense and defense.

Even the second unit has its share of doubts. While Marcus Smart brings grit, leadership, and defensive toughness, some fans believe he should start over Reaves to allow Doncic to dominate the ball more freely.

“Switch Smart and Reaves tbh so Luka can cook and second unit has a consistent scorer,” one fan suggested.

Without that adjustment, the bench unit could lack firepower, as many pointed out: “2nd unit going to struggle to score the rock.”

The Lakers’ depth at center is another sticking point. Beyond Ayton, the options are limited, and Jaxson Hayes has yet to prove he can be a reliable rotation player on a playoff-caliber team.

“Lol they cooked at center position still,” a fan bluntly observed.

For all the criticism, one thing is clear: expectations are sky-high. With Luka Doncic locked in for three more years and LeBron still capable of producing at an elite level, fans demand a rotation that can compete for a championship.

Whether the Lakers stick with their projected lineup or make adjustments as the season unfolds, the scrutiny will be relentless. Right now, though, much of the NBA world simply isn’t buying the balance, defense, or scoring punch of this potential rotation.