Yankees’ Michael Kay goes off on Mets’ Juan Soto for ‘tone deaf’ comments

Mets, Juan Soto
New York Mets’ Juan Soto reacts after striking out during the fifth inning of a baseball game against the New York Yankees, Sunday, July 6, 2025, in New York. (AP Photo/Adam Hunger)AP

Yankees announcer Michael Kay took issue with a comment Juan Soto made this week after the new Mets outfielder was left off the All-Star Game roster.

Speaking to reporters after the news broke, Soto said, “It happens,” and it’s “a part of baseball.” He was then asked a follow-up question about whether he wanted to play in the game.

“What do you think? I think it’s a lot of money on the table,” Soto said.

Kay made it clear on “The Michael Kay Show” on Wednesday that he wasn’t a fan of that comment.

“Oh, goodness gracious. Talk about being tone deaf,” Kay said. “C’mon, Juan. … You’re making a smidge under $47 million this season. And you’re upset you’re not making the All-Star Game because of an All-Star bonus that you have in your contract? Do you know how bad that looks that you said that? … Do you even realize how that makes you look?”

On top of players splitting a prize pool — in 2024, it was $640,000 split among 32 players on the winning team ($20,000 each) — Soto would have been owed $100,000, according to a bonus clause in his contract.

That’s a potential $120,000 squandered. Peanuts compared to the average annual value on his 15-year, $765 million contract ($51 million), but a lot of money nonetheless.

Soto has made the All-Star game four times in seven seasons (not including the COVID-shortened 2020 season). He was left off of the roster in his first two seasons and then he made the team four consecutive years.

 

Related Posts

Breaking!! One costly mistake could have ruined a young pitcher’s night. But Dave Roberts chose compassion over criticism. His reaction to Orion Kerkering’s moment is winning hearts everywhere.

Dodgers manager Dave Roberts shows sympathy for Orion Kerkering after costly mistake Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts showed support for Phillies pitcher Orion Kerkering after his…

METS BLOCKBUSTER MOVE Rumors heat up as a trade idea surfaces that could land an eight-time All-Star infielder in Queens shaking up the roster and sending shockwaves across the league..ll

For the Mets, the disaster that was the 2025 season is over. Now it’s time to start thinking about what moves can be made in the offseason.

METS REDEMPTION ARC Three coaches once unfairly fired now emerge as perfect comeback candidates to restore balance and bring good karma back to Queens..ll

The New York Mets have a whole lot of replacing to do. Several coaching vacancies, at least one of those spots could end up handed to a former Mets player and/o

⚾ Mets Internal Tensions: HLV and Steve Cohen Face High Stakes Ahead of New Season..ll

  As the 2026 MLB season approaches, the New York Mets are preparing for another intense campaign—but insiders report that tensions behind the scenes are heating up…

METS CONFRONT HARSH REALITY Steve Cohen forced to make tough financial call that could reshape the team’s future and leave fans anxiously waiting for the next move..ll

Tim Britton of The Athletic put together a fascinating story on the New York Mets and different payroll scenarios for the 2026 season. One scenario had the Mets

BOONE UNDER FIRE Fans erupt as Aaron Boone faces backlash for a ‘costly mistake’ that contributed to the Yankees’ playoff disaster leaving the season hanging by a thread and debates raging..ll

New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone is taking heat for one decision that may have led to his team’s abrupt elimination from the postseason.