Yankees Bring Back Veteran Pitcher Days After Parting Ways With Him

Yankees Bring Back Veteran Pitcher Days After Parting Ways With Him

Getty

Aaron Boone motions to the bullpen during the eighth inning of Game Five of the 2024 World Series.

The New York Yankees added some help to their bullpen by bringing back a familiar face this week.

The team designated pitcher Geoff Hartlieb for assignment earlier in the week and he opted for free agency, but quickly returned to the Bronx. The team announced that they signed Hartlieb, who ended up providing some help over the weekend.


Geoff Hartlieb Replaces Injured Pitcher

As SI.com’s Erin Shapland noted, the 31-year-old Hartlieb returned to the team to help replace Clarke Schmidt, who suffered an injury that is feared to be season ending. Hartlieb was a regular with the Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre RailRiders before being called up for Sunday’s series-ending win over the New York Mets.

Hartlieb could be a long-term addition for the Yankees, with Shapland noting that Schmidt is expected to be gone for a while.

“Schmidt was injured during his Thursday start against the Toronto Blue Jays, leaving the game after three innings with forearm tightness,” Shapland wrote. “He underwent an MRI when the team returned to New York after the losing series. Clarke will likely undergo Tommy John surgery in a devastating blow to the team’s struggling pitching rotation.”

Schmidt had been pulled from Thursday’s game against the Toronto Blue Jays after experiencing tightness in his arm.

“Earlier on in the game, it felt OK,” Schmidt said, via the Associated Press. “As the game progressed, it sort of tightened up a little bit on me.”

“I felt like the whole night I was kind of guarding it a little bit on the breaking balls, really not ripping them or trying to get a lot behind them,” he added.

The Yankees had a grim prognosis for Schmidt, with manager Aaron Boone saying he may need to undergo season-ending Tommy John surgery.


The Yankees sent pitcher Javien Sandridge down to Triple-A to make room for Hartlieb on the roster. Sandridge had been up and down between the Bronx and the minor leagues several times this season before finally making his debut this weekend against the Mets.

The Yankees could have more help on the way as reigning AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil is nearing his return. As Ian Casselberry of Yahoo Sports reported, Gil is expected to start a rehab assignment soon and could be back with the Yankees shortly after the All-Star break.

Casselberry noted that the Yankees could have some other options to help their pitching staff until Gil returns. That could include a rapid acceleration of one of the franchise’s top prospects, Cam Schlitter.

“Other internal starting pitching options for the Yankees could include Allan Winans, who struggled in a spot start but was excellent in Triple-A before being called up,” Casselberry wrote. “Brendan Beck was recently promoted to Triple-A, where he has a 2.93 ERA after three starts. In his 11 appearances at Double-A, he compiled a 1.82 ERA with 52 strikeouts in 54 1/3 innings. Cam Schlitter, ranked as the Yankees’ No. 10 prospect by MLB.com, has a 3.80 ERA in five Triple-A starts with an overall mark of 2.82 in the minors this season.”

Related Posts

METS RECAP: Ten painful losses told the story of the 2025 Mets — games where momentum turned to meltdown and potential turned to regret. From late-inning chaos to managerial missteps, each defeat revealed another flaw in a season full of near-misses. These weren’t just losses — they were lessons written in heartbreak..ll

The Mets missed the playoffs by a singular game, and one game would have made all the difference for this club

METS MAGIC: Juan Soto and Pete Alonso have shocked the league by landing as finalists for the prestigious Hank Aaron Award, putting New York back in the spotlight for all the right reasons. Their dominance at the plate has silenced critics and reignited hope in Queens. Two bats, one statement — the Mets are far from done..ll

Mets’ Juan Soto and Pete Alonso Shine as Hank Aaron Award Finalists In a show of explosive talent, New York Mets stars Juan Soto and Pete Alonso…

METS MELTDOWN: Chaos has hit New York as the team’s collapse fuels explosive trade talks centered on Nolan Arenado in a last-ditch bid for redemption. Front office urgency is peaking, insiders are leaking whispers of major roster shakeups, and tension is boiling over in the clubhouse. This isn’t just a rumor — it’s a desperate swing to save the season..ll

Mets’ Season Collapse Fuels Trade Talks for Arenado The New York Mets’ recent performance has drawn sharp criticism, marking one of the most disheartening conclusions to a…

YANKEES ON THE BRINK: New York faces Game 3 with their backs against the wall as the Blue Jays eye a ruthless sweep. The tension at home is palpable, and whispers inside the clubhouse hint at desperation and defiance clashing head-on. Everything — pride, legacy, and redemption — is on the line tonight..ll

Yankee Stadium can be a daunting place to play, even if the original House that Ruth Built was across the road. A rabid fanbase will make sure of that when the American League Division Series resumes Tuesday at 8:08 p.m. ET between New York and the Toronto Blue Jays.

YANKEES COLLAPSE: Two brutal losses in Toronto have pushed New York to the brink, and the trip home feels heavier than ever. The bats went silent, the pitching fell apart, and frustration is starting to spill over behind the scenes. One more misstep, and the season could be over before anyone’s ready to admit it..ll

TORONTO (AP) — After back-to-back beatdowns in Toronto, the New York Yankees don’t have any margin for error as they head home for Game 3 of the ALDS on Tuesday night. Yankees manager Aaron Boone put on a brave face after a 13-7 loss Sunday in Game 2 left his team facing elimination. “Obviously, it […]

YANKEES ALERT: Aaron Boone just dropped hints about major lineup changes ahead of Game 3 against the Blue Jays, and insiders say it could shake up everything. Quiet confidence mixed with urgency has the clubhouse buzzing, as key roles may be shifting when it matters most. One bold move could decide the entire series..ll

New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone hints at potential big lineup changes for Game 3 of the ALDS vs. the Toronto Blue Jays.