Chiefs are making a familiar mistake with first-round pick Josh Simmons

Josh Simmons reflects on how much Justin Frye meant to his development

Here are two true statements. First, the Kansas City Chiefs need help along their offensive line after a season that saw Patrick Mahomes take a career-high 36 sacks.

Second, the Chiefs used a first-round pick on offensive lineman Josh Simmons in this year’s NFL Draft, but fans shouldn’t pin all their hopes on Simmons fixing this offensive line immediately.

That’s especially true when you consider that not only is Simmons a rookie, but he’s coming off a torn patellar tendon last season at Ohio State. Expecting him to step in and be the immediate starter at left tackle — the most important offensive line position — feels like a miscalculation.

It also feels exactly like what the Chiefs are planning to do.

Josh Simmons is probably going to be good, but he’s also coming off a major injury

ESPN’s Adam Teicher reported that the Chiefs used Simmons as the starting left tackle during OTAs. Which, hey — that’s fine! Get him some reps!

But these were also noncontact reps. We need to see if Simmons and, more specifically, Simmons’ knee is going to hold up once contact starts before we anoint him as the savior of this offensive line. It sounds like he’s on track to start Week 1, but we haven’t even gotten to the real test yet.

The Chiefs don’t need to rush things with Simmons. Look, for example, at last year’s second-round pick, Kingsley Suamataia, a second-round pick out of BYU who started just two games for the team last year. Those two games happened to be Week 1 and Week 2, and it became clear immediately that he wasn’t ready for the left tackle role, which led to him being benched for Wanya Morris. Now, we’re in just Suamataia’s second season, and he’s already been moved to guard and is no longer in the left tackle battle.

Maybe some patience with Simmons will prevent a repeat of 2024. The Chiefs signed former 49ers tackle Jaylon Moore to a two-year, $30 million deal this offseason, but as of now, it appears he’ll be a backup for Kansas City. Why not take a bit of a cautious approach with Simmons and see what Moore can do?

Playing a guy too early can have long-term consequences. Even putting the injury situation with Simmons aside, if he goes out there, struggles like Suamataia did, and then gets benched for Moore a month into the season, you’ve killed his confidence. This isn’t a rebuilding team that can let a rookie make mistakes at the most important spot on the line — if he’s not producing early on, Andy Reid will have to make a move.

Right now, it feels like a lot of pressure is being placed on Simmons, just like how last year, a lot of pressure was being placed on Suamataia. Is Kansas City going to make the same mistake two years in a row? The potential good news, if they do, is that a pre-injury Simmons had a lot more hype around him than Suamataia, so maybe he’ll be a good-enough player to make a tough situation work. Still, it’s not a great spot to be in as a young player.

Related Posts

BREAKING : Chiefs quietly add versatile defender for game against Chicago Bears

The Chiefs have a new linebacker under the microscope in the team’s final preseason game.

UPDATE : Chiefs make last-minute deal ahead of Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season.

Here we’ll try to look at and discuss the last-minute trade that the Kansas City Chiefs must make before Week 1 of 2025 NFL season.

1 last-minute trade Chiefs must make before Week 1 of 2025 NFL season

Here we’ll try to look at and discuss the last-minute trade that the Kansas City Chiefs must make before Week 1 of 2025 NFL season.

EXTREMELY HARD: Paul Finebaum mocks Kansas City Chiefs, Andy Reid responds with 3 words that make fans explode.

In a moment that has sent shockwaves across the NFL community, college football analyst Paul Finebaum has once again found himself in the center of

💚💛 PACKERS FANS, IMAGINE THIS 💛💚 “Thіѕ іѕ the beѕt newѕ we could hoрe for…” 👀🔥 What іf the legendary Brett Favre returned to Green Bay — not aѕ a рlayer, but aѕ the head coach? 🏈 Pіcture hіm back at Lambeau Fіeld, brіngіng hoрe, рaѕѕіon, and іnѕріratіon whіle overcomіng рerѕonal challengeѕ 🙌. Would the Packerѕ become unѕtoррable under Favre’ѕ leaderѕhір? 👇

The Green Bay Packers have stunned the football world with the announcement that Brett Favre, one of the most iconic quarterbacks in NFL history, will be

🏆 CONGRATULATIONS 🏆 Kanѕaѕ Cіty Chіefѕ legend Jamaal Charleѕ haѕ offіcіally been іnducted іnto the Pro Football Hall of Fame after yearѕ of unforgettable ѕervіce to the team ❤️💛. In an emotіonal ѕtatement to hіѕ fanѕ, Charleѕ ѕhared wordѕ that every Chіefѕ ѕuррorter wіll carry wіth рrіde 🙌. A true legend. A true Chіef. 🏈🔥

Kansas City is celebrating in red and gold today as legendary running back Jamaal Charles has officially been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.