Top MLB insider reveals specific All-Star New York Yankees prefer as potential Juan Soto replacement

If the New York Yankees shockingly lose Juan Soto in free agency this offseason, a prominent MLB insider has revealed the player they would prefer to be his replacement in the outfield next season.

This is going to be a huge next couple of weeks for the Yankees. The team is primed to be a World Series contender again in 2025. But only if they hold on to one key player: Juan Soto. The 26-year-old is the jewel of this year’s free agent class and will receive offers from many wealthy and powerful clubs.

Related: Top MLB insider reveals how many years Juan Soto wants in contract from Mets, Yankees, and Blue Jays and it’s insane

New York is the favorite in what will be a highly competitive race for Soto. Nevertheless, there is a very real chance that in-city rivals the New York Mets, and division rivals the Toronto Blue Jays could lure away a player that played a massive role in the Yankees reaching the World Series in October.

That is why the organization must have plans in place in case the worst-case scenario occurs. The team has been linked to several major players in free agency over the last couple of weeks. However, on Tuesday the player they specifically want to replace Soto in the outfield may have been revealed.

New York Yankees have serious interest in Teoscar Hernandez

Top MLB insider reveals specific All-Star New York Yankees prefer as potential Juan Soto replacement
Credit: Kiyoshi Mio-Imagn Images

During the 2024 World Series, the New York Yankees got a taste of what two-time All-Star Teoscar Hernandez brings to a team. He was one of the many high-priced stars the Los Angeles Dodgers signed a year ago. And he played a key role in their championship season this year.

His performance in 2024 certainly made an impression on the Yankees and it’s probably why ESPN MLB insider Jeff Passan reported on Tuesday that “the Yankees want him if Soto doesn’t come back.”

  • Teoscar Hernandez stats (2024): .272 AVG, .339 OBP, .501 SLG, .840 OPS, 33 HR, 99 RBI, 84 R

However, Passan did offer up a couple of key warnings about the Yankees’ chances of signing the 32-year-old. Firstly, the Dodgers are favored to re-sign him. Plus, both the Boston Red Sox and Baltimore Orioles will be serious players for his services as well.

Secondly, Passan claims “Chances are Hernández will be one of the first big names off the board.” So by the time they figure out where they stand with Soto, the outfielder probably won’t be available.

Related: Worrisome scouting report on New York Yankees ‘lazy’ approach detailed by Los Angeles Dodgers player

Related Posts

🔥 TRADE ALERT: A new report suggests the Mets might be putting Kodai Senga on the market in a blockbuster deal, speculation is heating up over which stars could be involved, and if the trade goes through, it could instantly reshape the team’s rotation and the league landscape…ll

A new report suggests that the New York Mets may be shopping Kodai Senga, as the right-handed starter’s success may be short lived.

❄️ WINTER BLOCKBUSTER?: Fresh rumors hint at a potential Mets-Rangers mega trade this winter, insiders are buzzing about the star-studded swap that could shake the league, and if it happens, it might redefine both teams’ championship paths in one fell swoop…ll

Some new MLB rumors make the Mets and Rangers perfect trade partners for an intriguing blockbuster deal this winter.

💸 MILLION‑DOLLAR DEMAND: Rumors swirl that Edwin Diaz is angling for another $100 million from the Mets, rival teams like the Blue Jays, Tigers, and Braves are circling, and if negotiations explode, it could trigger a frenzy that reshapes the bullpen market entirely…ll

Reliever Edwin Diaz has outlined his contract demands for the New York Mets, who now have a big decision to make.

🔥 TRADE BOMBSHELL: The Mets could shake up the league by packaging three key players for Ketel Marte, insiders are buzzing over which combination could land the star, and if the deal goes through, it might instantly transform the team into a championship contender…ll

If there’s one thing the hot stove never runs out of, it’s intrigue—and Bob Nightengale just poured another log on the fire. The timing couldn’t be better, with

💥 BLOCKBUSTER HUNT: The Yankees are reportedly eyeing a massive Paul Skenes trade, rumors are swirling about a deal that could shake the league to its core, and if it happens, it might redefine the team’s championship trajectory in ways no one saw coming…ll

The Yankees are always looking for difference-makers in the rotation, and there are reports suggesting that Paul Skenes is desperate to put on the pinstripes

🚨 SCOUTING SHOCKER: The Yankees just fired a top scouting executive after high-profile signings completely missed the mark, tensions are boiling behind the scenes, and if the shake-up continues, it could signal a dramatic shift in how the team builds for the future…ll

The Yankees reportedly fired their international scouting director.