Yankees Predicted to Make Harsh Giancarlo Stanton Decision: ‘Don’t Have Room’

Giancarlo Stanton's Legendary Power Is Unmatched, Both In The Statcast Era And In Tall Tales

The New York Yankees have sprinted out to baseball’s best offensive start despite losing some critical contributors.

Chiefly, the team lost superstar slugger Juan Soto to the crosstown rival New York Mets this past winter, but that doesn’t seem to have fazed the batting order. The Yankees lead all teams in homers, RBI, on-base percentage and more.

Franchise slugger Aaron Judge deserves most of the credit for that success, while veteran first baseman Paul Goldschmidt has contributed mightily as well. And a slew of surprises, including Trent Grisham, Austin Wells and Ben Rice, are adding significant power.

But with so many hot bats, the Yankees face a tough decision on veteran designated Giancarlo Stanton as he works his way back from injury.

“(The) Yankees don’t have room for Giancarlo Stanton to play regularly,” Zachary Rotman wrote for FanSided. “Even without Stanton, the Yankees have more bats than spots right now. … This is ultimately a good problem for the Yankees to have, but the same can’t exactly be said for Stanton, who would presumably love to play as much as he can.”

After hitting the injured list with elbow problems to start the season, Stanton has been working to return to the team and could be ready before June. But the Yankees’ options for getting his bat back into the lineup are limited.

He almost certainly can’t play a defensive position after taking on an exclusive designated hitter role for all of last year. And logjams throughout the roster mean that Rice is difficult to slot in on defense without learning a new position, which is a difficult ask.

Ultimately, it could mean Stanton sits on the bench on a regular basis, which would be a harsh move for a $325 million player.

“The Yankees won’t bench Stanton permanently, but the odds of him playing regularly, given the team’s logjam, are slim to none,” Rotman projected.

If this situation persists with Stanton back to healthy form, it’s possible that the Yankees will be looking for trade suitors.

 

Related Posts

METS BLOCKBUSTER MOVE Rumors heat up as a trade idea surfaces that could land an eight-time All-Star infielder in Queens shaking up the roster and sending shockwaves across the league..ll

For the Mets, the disaster that was the 2025 season is over. Now it’s time to start thinking about what moves can be made in the offseason.

METS REDEMPTION ARC Three coaches once unfairly fired now emerge as perfect comeback candidates to restore balance and bring good karma back to Queens..ll

The New York Mets have a whole lot of replacing to do. Several coaching vacancies, at least one of those spots could end up handed to a former Mets player and/o

⚾ Mets Internal Tensions: HLV and Steve Cohen Face High Stakes Ahead of New Season..ll

  As the 2026 MLB season approaches, the New York Mets are preparing for another intense campaign—but insiders report that tensions behind the scenes are heating up…

METS CONFRONT HARSH REALITY Steve Cohen forced to make tough financial call that could reshape the team’s future and leave fans anxiously waiting for the next move..ll

Tim Britton of The Athletic put together a fascinating story on the New York Mets and different payroll scenarios for the 2026 season. One scenario had the Mets

BOONE UNDER FIRE Fans erupt as Aaron Boone faces backlash for a ‘costly mistake’ that contributed to the Yankees’ playoff disaster leaving the season hanging by a thread and debates raging..ll

New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone is taking heat for one decision that may have led to his team’s abrupt elimination from the postseason.

⚾ Yankees Internal Turmoil: Tensions Between Aaron Boone and President Brian Cashman After Playoff Exit

After the New York Yankees were eliminated from the 2025 playoffs, tensions between manager Aaron Boone and team president Brian Cashman have reportedly reached a boiling point….