NEW YORK (AP) – Brett Baty almost became an afterthought as he slipped down the New York Mets’ depth chart.
Think again.
A once-prized prospect who had lost his luster, Baty is finally beginning to break out in the big leagues. The 25-year-old infielder continued a surprising resurgence Tuesday night with his fourth home run in five days, a tiebreaking shot in the seventh inning that sent New York to a 2-1 win over the Pittsburgh Pirates.
“I´ve always thought I would be capable of doing whatever I wanted to accomplish in this game,” Baty said. “I´m having some success right now and it’s nice.”
Recalled from the minors last week, Baty is batting .333 (13 for 39) with five homers and eight extra-base hits in his last 12 starts for the Mets.
“Confidence. Guy that knows he belongs in the big leagues. And just having fun. He’s preparing, he´s going out there, keeping it simple, getting good pitches to hit and just not overthinking it,” manager Carlos Mendoza said. “I´m just glad that he´s finally settling in and getting comfortable at this level.”
New York Mets’ Brett Baty follows through on a home run during the seventh inning of a baseball game against the Pittsburgh Pirates Tuesday, May 13, 2025, in New York. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)
Selected 12th overall by the Mets in the 2019 amateur draft, Baty squandered a couple of opportunities to hold down the everyday job at third base as he struggled at the plate the past two years. He was demoted to the minors in 2024 and spent much of the season with Triple-A Syracuse.
Meanwhile, buddy Mark Vientos took hold of the hot corner by hitting .266 with 27 homers, 71 RBIs and an .837 OPS last year – and then having a huge postseason.
Baty started playing some second base in the minors to provide versatility, and he made New York’s opening-day roster this year in a part-time bench role, with second baseman and outfielder Jeff McNeil on the injured list. But when McNeil returned April 24, it was back to Syracuse for Baty.
Mendoza, however, said he told Baty he was being sent down only because of the roster crunch – not because he didn’t perform well. And that message seems to have made a difference.
“I feel like every young player, when they first come up to the big leagues, they´re always looking to impress or trying to do a little too much, trying to have success or results out of the gate,” Mendoza said. “And sometimes it takes a lot longer for guys. This guy performed at the minor league level and then for some reason it took some time for him to get comfortable here.”
It wasn’t long before Baty was back in New York. He got recalled May 5 when fellow left-handed hitter Jesse Winker went on the injured list – and Baty has taken off since.
“I think everybody´s journey in this game is different and I´m thankful for every single part of mine, for sure,” he said.
With two outs in the seventh Tuesday night, Baty lined a 1-1 changeup from Pirates starter Mitch Keller the other way and off the railing just above the left-field wall at Citi Field to give the Mets a 2-1 lead.
“I thought it was a line drive maybe over the left fielder´s head,” Mendoza said. “Just kept on going. Pretty impressive. Big league power right there.”
It was Baty’s fifth major league home run this season and fourth in his last four games with a plate appearance. He’s raised his batting average to .239 with a productive .791 OPS in 25 games.
“I just feel like right now, I´m kind of focused on driving the pitch that I want to drive instead of just swinging at strikes,” said Baty, who started at second base and shifted to third for defense in the ninth.
His teammates on the first-place Mets (28-15) have taken notice, too.
“I love having him on the team. I think he looks very confident up there, and he has the potential and the power to hit it out of the ballpark at any part of the ballpark,” Mets pitcher Kodai Senga said through a translator. “If he was an opposing hitter, I think any pitcher would not like to face him.”
