RUMOR TRADE: Yankees Predicted to Land 3-Time Cy Young Winner in Free Agency

Yankees Predicted to Land 3-Time Cy Young Winner in Free Agency

Getty Yankees linked to signing Max Scherzer.

The New York Yankees will likely land a starter or two in free agency and one prediction has them landing a future Hall of Famer.

In MLBTradeRumors’ annual Top 50 MLB free agents and predictions, Anthony Franco has the Yankees landing Max Scherzer to a one-year $16 million deal.

“Despite all the health concerns, Scherzer was still good when on the mound. He posted a 3.95 ERA, 22.6% strikeout rate and 5.6% walk rate,” the article said. “He won’t be able to get the massive $43.33MM average annual value he got on his last deal, but plenty of late-career veterans have secured solid one-year deals lately. Zack Greinke got $13MM from the Royals a few years ago to serve as a veteran innings eater. He didn’t have health flags like Scherzer but his effectiveness was waning. Scherzer has an elite track record and can still compete at a high level when on the hill.”

Scherzer is 40 years old and has been in the MLB since the 2008 season. He is an eight-time MLB All-Star and three-time Cy Young winner, last winning the award in 2017.

The right-hander dealt with injuries last season as he made just 9 starts with the Texas Rangers going 2-4 with a 3.95 ERA over 43.1 innings. In his MLB career, Scherzer is 216-112 with a 3.16 ERA.


How Would Scherzer Fit in With the Yankees?

If New York does sign Scherzer to the one-year deal he would be the team’s fourth or fifth starter in the 2025 MLB season. Scherzer is also a winner as he’s a two-time World Series champion.

The Yankees ace is Gerrit Cole who signed a four-year extension with New York. Behind him, the Yankees have Clarke Schmidt, Carlos Rodon, Luis Gil, Nestor Cortes, and Marcus Stroman all competing for rotation spots.

However, the future of Gil, Cortes, and Stroman has been up in the air, so adding Scherzer would give New York another veteran starter.

Although Scherzer is no longer the ace he was, he could be a solid fifth starter who could give New York five innings per start.


Yankees Bring Back Cole

New York signed Cole to a four-year, $144 million contract, the same deal that he opted out of.

Cole opted out of the deal in hopes the Yankees would add the one-year $36 million extension to his contract, making it a five-year, $180 million deal.

However, the sides decided to stick to the original four-year $144 million deal which general manager Brian Cashman says was ideal.

“It was something at the moment we weren’t necessarily comfortable doing, but we wanted our player and our ace back, and he certainly didn’t want to go either at the same time,” Yankees GM Brian Cashman said at the general manager’s meetings in Texas, via ESPN “And so we had a lot of healthy dialogue about trying to just thread the needle and just keep it in play…

“It felt like we were going to be in a safe harbor where we were both willing to move forward with the four years that was in play and continue obviously to have conversations,” Cashman added. “But there’s no pressure point with any conversations. We’re always open to talk about future years, but right now we don’t have to because it’s a four-year locked-in commitment, and it’s on to our next focus.”

Last season, Cole went 8-5 with a 3.41 ERA in 17 starts.

Cole Shelton covers the NHL for Heavy.com. He has covered pro and college sports since 2016, including bylines at BJ Penn, USA Today, SB Nation, Rotowire, Canadian Baseball Network and more. More about Cole Shelton

More Heavy on Yankees News

Loading more stories

Related Posts

BREAKING UPDATE: Dodgers skipper Dave Roberts has officially revealed that Roki Sasaki has “earned” his trust, setting the stage for the young phenom to claim a playoff roster spot. The bold statement has fans electrified, with whispers that Sasaki’s arrival could ignite a historic October run

Dodgerѕ’ Dave Robertѕ revealѕ Rokі ѕaѕakі ‘earned’ hіѕ truѕt, exрectѕ рlayoff roѕter ѕрot After two great ѕhowіng out of the Dodgerѕ bullрen, Dave Robertѕ revealѕ that Rokі…

🚨 BREAKING INSIDE SCOOP: Dave Roberts just dropped a bombshell hint that the Dodgers may unleash their $12M elite defensive weapon for the postseason clash with the Reds, a move that could change everything. Fans are already buzzing over the shocking possibility, wondering if this secret card is the game-changer October has been waiting for

Dodgers’ manager Dave Roberts hints $12M elite defensive weapon for postseason roster vs. Reds Kirby Lee-Imagn Images The Los Angeles Dodgers are preparing to face the Cincinnati Reds in the Wild…

EXCLUSIVE REPORT: Insiders confirm the Dodgers’ roster plans may be shaken after dramatic medical updates, fueling speculation about how the team will adjust in the do-or-die clash. The uncertainty has Reds fans celebrating early while Dodgers Nation braces for a rollercoaster ride

Dodgers Get a Pair of Key Injury Updates Ahead of Wild-Card Matchup vs. Reds Los Angeles Dodgers third baseman Max Muncy expects to be ready to play…

Breaking: Dave Roberts confirms Dodgers’ $6M reliever will make postseason roster despite lackluster season

Dave Robertѕ confіrmѕ Dodgerѕ’ $6M relіever wіll make рoѕtѕeaѕon roѕter deѕріte lackluѕter ѕeaѕon The Loѕ Angeleѕ Dodgerѕ are lookіng to break a long-ѕtandіng MLB curѕe: wіnnіng back-to-back chamріonѕhірѕ. Whіle…

💰METS FINANCIAL SHOCK: NY host calls the Mets’ failed season a “financial disaster,” fans erupted as social feeds filled with outrage, debate, and speculation, analysts scrambled to break down the money mistakes while team executives remained under pressure, now the burning question is… how deep does the financial fallout really go?.. ll

Mets’ failed season was a ‘financial disaster,’ Boomer Esiason says.

⚡FORMER METS SPOTLIGHT: A look at how former Mets players are making waves in this year’s playoff field, fans erupted as social feeds filled with highlights, debates, and speculation, analysts scrambled to assess their impact on new teams while commentators dissected every performance, now the burning question is… who among them could change the postseason story?.. ll

Featuring the player traded for Javier Báez, the player DFA’d for Javier Báez, and also Javier Báez.