There are two clear resolutions to the Marcus Stroman situation at Yankees camp.
First, if Yankees suffer an injury within their starting staff, Stroman takes his place.
As the Yankees experienced last March, an injury can happen at any moment. Ace Gerrit Cole hurt his elbow, was shut down and Luis Gil won the subsequent competition to fill his shoes, turning the roster spot into the beginning of an electric Rookie of the Year campaign.
Stroman would be the favorite to take a rotation spot if Cole, Max Fried, Gil, Carlos Rodón or Clarke Schmidt couldn’t start the regular season on time.
In that sense, it’s a no-brainer to get Stroman ready to be a starter. It doesn’t sound like they have a choice either as Stroman was adamant on Friday that he won’t pitch out of the bullpen.
Second, the Yankees find a trade partner and move Stroman before Opening Day.
No team is immune to injury adversity. Another club could get slammed with unforeseen circumstances over these next six weeks and call the Yankees as they search for an available innings eater.
Stroman’s $18 million salary will make those negotiations tough. There’s his vesting option for 2026 as well, another $18 million if he eclipses the 140-inning mark this year. Teams could be turned off by the way the right-hander finished last season or by his track record of speaking his mind on social media and to reporters as well. If it was easy to trade Stroman, the Yankees would’ve done it already.
But at that stage, later in camp, teams could be desperate. The free agent market for starting pitching is running thin and not every club has a surplus of starters, let alone pitchers they’d be willing to move before the season begins.
If the Yankees are willing to eat some of Stroman’s salary and another team truly needs an arm, those conversations can progress. It’s contingent, of course, on the rest of the Yankees’ five-man staff staying healthy. That’s when Stroman truly becomes expendable.
There is a third option here, though.
It’s unlikely, and isn’t a preferred outcome, but both manager Aaron Boone and general manager Brian Cashman didn’t completely shoot it down when asked about it on Friday.
What if the Yankees roll with a six-man rotation to begin the year?
Other teams, like the defending champion Dodgers, have used that strategy to lessen the workload on a staff overflowing with talent.
“Never say never,” Boone told reporters at George M. Steinbrenner Field. “I mean, I don’t necessarily see us doing that, but we’ll see where we’re at. Again, that’s a long way away. Reality is we’re probably getting 10, 11 guys ready to be starters and who knows how many of them you’re gonna have to use right away or at some point during the season? I’ll never say never, but I’m not looking at it as we’re gonna have a six-man.”
The issue with a six-man staff is it means everybody is taking the ball less frequently. Would the Yankees be comfortable with Cole and Fried starting only five times over the team’s first 30 games of the year rather than six, for instance?
A better question — as Cashman pointed out during spring training media day in Bradenton, Fla. — is would Stroman’s teammates be on board with that scenario? And would pitching coach Matt Blake and his staff think it’s in the team’s best interest?
Without naming any names, Cashman recalled a scenario years ago where a handful of Yankees starters wanted to swap to a four-man rotation down the stretch. One pitcher wasn’t interested and the plan fell through.
“I share that with it also being personnel dependent and buy-in dependent,” Cashman explained. “From a manager or coaching staff, you engage your players about their comfort level. … Then you get their feedback and their buy-in, or lack thereof. You factor it in and you make an ultimate call in the end of what is your north star with all that information.”
Keeping Stroman on the roster as a sixth starter would also make the bullpen thinner. Rather than eight arms, there would be seven. Then, when the bullpen suddenly has to handle more innings than planned in a given stretch, there will be issues in relief when starters don’t provide length.
This entire saga is a good problem to have in the sense that the Yankees have more starters than they need. This time of year, you truly can’t have too much pitching. It also won’t become an actual problem until the Yankees need to make final roster cuts and head north for Opening Day.
That’s why Cashman was preaching patience throughout his availalility.
“Clearly we’ve collected a lot of really high quality starters,” he said, “so just give us time to work through it.”
- Yankees’ Devin Williams opens up on huge success, Mariano Rivera, playoff failures
- Marcus Stroman is challenging Yankees in a game of chicken: He can’t win | Klapisch
- Yankees high on Jasson Domínguez contingency plan in outfield
- Is Nolan Arenado on Yankees’ radar? Can they afford him? Here’s Brian Cashman’s take
- How Yankees are addressing Japanese rut with record-setting slugger coming to MLB in 2026
Thank you for relying on us to provide the journalism you can trust. Please consider supporting us with a subscription.
Max Goodman may be reached at [email protected].
If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.