REPORT: Super Bowl proved the Brady-Mahomes race just isn’t that close

All I know is that Tom Brady would NEVER!

Down 34-0 near the end of the third? And 40-6 halfway through the fourth? A MAJOR factor in his team’s Super Bowl disintegration with the planet watching?

Tom Brady dealt with diabolical four-man rush defenses in Super Bowls. Twice.

He got the snot beat out of him in the 2007 Super Bowl by the Giants and Steve Spagnuolo’s front. He still put the Patriots ahead 14-10 with 2:45 left in the fourth and hit Randy Moss in the hands from 70 yards away on a third-and-20 from his own 16-yard line with 19 seconds remaining, one play after getting SAWED IN HALF by Jay Alford.

Less snot was beaten from him in 2011 when, with a lesser supporting cast than 2007, he hit Wes Welker in the hands with a would-be game sealer that was dropped. On the final play of the game with the Patriots trailing 21-17, he hit Aaron Hernandez in the hands with a Hail Mary that was tipped and fell just short of a diving Rob Gronkowski.

He got smacked up by the Eagles in 2017 — nine quarterback hits compared to one for Nick Foles — and still threw for a Super Bowl-record 505 yards.

I don’t know if I’ve ever seen a more merciless beating than Brady took in the 2015 AFC Championship Game against Denver, but there he was hitting Gronk on fourth-and-10 from the 50-yard line for 40 yards with 1:34 left to set up a touchdown on fourth-and-4 with 17 seconds left that made it 20-18. The two-point conversion failed.

And those are the losses!

At halftime Sunday night, the stage was set for Patrick Mahomes to win his third in a row AND erase a massive deficit like Brady did against the Falcons in 2016. It only got worse.

There was a point you knew Mahomes was dead. Brady never died. I’m not here to bury Mahomes. He belongs in the top-five conversation. Even the top three. But you can’t put a lesser god up on the same mountaintop with Zeus.

I mentioned last week that the Brady-Mahomes GOAT debate is great fodder, but Mahomes is barely halfway up Everest.

Julian Edelman joins Tom Curran on the Patriots Talk podcast and shares his thoughts on the Tom Brady-Patrick Mahomes debate and why the former Patriots QB still holds the edge in the ‘GOAT’ QB debate.

Brady didn’t just win seven Super Bowls. He woulda-shoulda-coulda won them in 2006 (gag job in Indy), 2007 (helmet catch), 2011 (aforementioned missed connection with Welker), 2015 (embarrassing OL and skill position performance, plus Jamie Collins getting got twice by Owen Daniels) and 2017 (Malcolm Butler sits; Foles goes off).

It’s like the Jack Nicklaus-Tiger Woods debate. Nicklaus won 18 majors. Woods won 15. Nicklaus was runner-up in a major 19 times! Woods has seven.

Tom Brady was a long way from infallible in Super Bowls or elimination games. The guy took a friggin’ unforced SAFETY on the first drive of Super Bowl XLVI against the Giants. He threw a dumbass red-zone pick against the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl XXXVIII.

He threw an almost-pick-6 to Denver’s Champ Bailey in 2005 which killed the Patriots’ chances for a three-peat and handed Brady his first playoff loss after a still-record 10-0 start to his playoff career. His pick ended the final drive in the 2006 AFCCG. And so on.

But nobody — perhaps in American pro sports history — could ever do the Lazarus act like Brady. Even when he didn’t rise fully from the dead, you had to pry games from his cold, dead hands.

He never got his face blown off like Peyton Manning did by Seattle in 2012. Like Mahomes did Sunday. Like Joe Montana did in 1986 when his Niners lost 49-3 to the Giants, or when he got benched in 1987 in the Divisional Round against the Vikings. Like John Elway when he lost by a combined 96 points in his first three trips to the Super Bowl.

That’s pretty much my top five quarterbacks in NFL history. Brady, Mahomes, Montana, Elway, Manning.

Do you understand what I’m saying here? And that’s not even getting to 41-year-old Tom Brady tearing the Chiefs’ heart out in the 2018 AFC Championship Game or 43-year-old Brady beating Mahomes and the Chiefs by 22 in the 2020 Super Bowl.

You can “Yeah, but …” all you want. Bring up the greatness of Bill Belichick and say that’s points-against for Brady to have had the best coach ever. Fine. What’s Andy Reid? What was Bill Walsh?

Brady had too many weapons with Gronk and Moss? Moss was given up on by the time he got to New England. And still wasn’t as great as Jerry Rice. And haven’t we been hearing about the brilliance of Travis Kelce non-stop for four years?

I did not — I swear — go into Sunday’s game wanting to see Mahomes fall apart limb-by-limb and the Chiefs’ pursuit of history thwarted.

I like having covered the greatest dynasty in NFL history and being fortunate enough to have had the greatest opportunity any reporter ever had over a 25-year stretch. But I don’t think another team elevating diminishes that. And I also didn’t think the Chiefs or Mahomes were truly close to what the Patriots accomplished.

As I’ve said before, they are about halfway home. Mahomes is 3-2 in Super Bowls after five of them, just like Brady was. Just like the Patriots were from 2001 to 2011.

The man’s got time. But he’s still only halfway up the mountain.

Related Posts

EMOTIONAL TRIUMPH: Taylor Swіft’ѕ Dad, Scott Swіft, Releaѕed from Naѕhvіlle Hoѕріtal After Lіfe-Savіng Heart Surgery — Taylor and Travіѕ Kelce Tear Uр aѕ Fanѕ Send Thouѕandѕ of Well-Wіѕheѕ!!!

EMOTIONAL TRIUMPH: Taylor Swift’s Dad, Scott Swift, Released from Nashville Hospital After Life-Savi

SECRET VOWS: Taylor Swіft and Travіѕ Kelce Allegedly Exchange Prіvate Promіѕeѕ at a Moonlіt Lake Como Retreat — Iѕ a Secret Ceremony іn Theіr Future???

SECRET VOWS: Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Allegedly Exchange Private Promises at a Moonlit Lake Com

Travіѕ Kelce & Taylor Swіft Fіnally Sріll Juіcy Secretѕ About Theіr Sweet Date Nіght After the ACC Golf—What Really Haррened Off-Camera Leaveѕ Fanѕ Stunned!

Travіѕ Kelce &amр;amр; Taylor ѕwіft Fіnally ѕріll Juіcy ѕecretѕ About Theіr ѕweet Date Nіght After the ACC Golf—What Really Haррened Off-Camera Leaveѕ Fanѕ ѕtunned!  іn a heartwarmіng…

Jaѕon Kelce Breakѕ Down іn Tearѕ aѕ He Sendѕ Heart-Wrenchіng Condolenceѕ to Taylor Swіft’ѕ Famіly After Scott Swіft’ѕ Tragіc Emergency—What Really Haррened Behіnd the Sceneѕ???

Jason Kelce Breaks Down in Tears as He Sends Heart-Wrenching Condolences to Taylor Swift’s Family After Scott Swift’s Tragic Emergency—What Really Happened Behind the Scenes? Jason Kelce Breaks Down in Tears as He Sends Heart-Wrenching Condolences to Taylor Swift’s Family After Scott Swift’s Tragic Emergency—What Really Happened Behind the Scenes? ✅ What did happen 1. […]

Dіd He Juѕt Call Her Hіѕ Wіfe?!” — Travіѕ Kelce Stunѕ Fanѕ by Introducіng Taylor Swіft aѕ Hіѕ ‘Wіfe’ Durіng Shockіng Club Moment іn Naѕhvіlle on July 16, 2025

Did He Just Call Her His Wife?!” — Travis Kelce Stuns Fans by Introducing Taylor Swift as His ‘Wife’ During Shocking Club Moment in Nashville on July 16, 2025  🎥 The Viral Club Moment: What Happened? A fan-captured video shot at a club in Nashville during the recent Tight End University event shows Kansas City […]

Travіѕ Kelce Breakѕ Down on Podcaѕt: Shockіng Revelatіon About Taylor Swіft’ѕ Dad Scott Swіft After Emergency Heart Surgery—Fanѕ Stunned by Emotіonal Health Uрdate on ‘New Heіghtѕ’

Travis Kelce Steps Up as Taylor Swift’s Dad Scott Swift Recovers from Major Heart Surgery In mid‑June 2025, Scott Kingsley Swift, 73, underwent a quintuple coronary artery bypass grafting surgery—a complex procedure involving the creation of five new blood flow paths around blocked coronary arteries. The surgery was prompted not by a heart attack but […]