RISKY BUSINESS: Yankees Bet Big on Bullpen Over Proven Free Agents

The New York Yankees could have signed the top left-handed reliever on the free agent market any time in the last two months, but they passed on Tanner Scott.

They let the Los Angeles Dodgers grab yet another of the top available talents on the market. So the Yankees are less than a month away from spring training and have just two left-handed pitchers — Max Fried and Carlos Rodon — on their 40-man roster. On this one, however, the Yankees deserve a pass.

They have a good track record of finding diamonds in the rough and turning them into valuable relievers. And that is what NJ.com beat writer Max Goodman suggests they will do this season to get a lefty in the bullpen. “Either way, don’t be surprised if the Yankees bring a few possible reclamation projects along when they report to camp. That’s been their specialty over these last few years, bringing the best out of pitchers who are desperate to turn their careers around. After all, it doesn’t get more cost-effective than that,” Goodman wrote.

Over the past four seasons, under pitching coach Matt Blake, the Yankees have proven that they can find the “market inefficiencies” in relief pitching. They have taken relievers who were previously unremarkable, honed in on one or two strengths, and made them into bullpen weapons. Blake honed Clay Holmes’s sinker after they acquired him from the Pirates until he was one of the best closers in the game for two seasons. Blake worked on Luke Weaver’s rising four-seam fastball, turning him from a failed starter into the Yankees’ closer in the World Series. Left-hander Tim Hill had a similar resurgence after the Yankees acquired him from the White Sox last season. A reunion with the lefty side-armer isn’t out of the question

. The Yankees have also been linked to veteran left-handers Andrew Chafin and Brooks Raley. But it would not be surprising to see the Yankees invite guys like Will Smith, Ryan Yarbrough, Jake Diekman, Colin Poche or Danny Coulombe to camp and see if Blake can work his magic on them.

Related Posts

⚾ Mets Trio Named NL Silver Slugger Award Finalists: Pete Alonso, Francisco Lindor, and Juan Soto ..ll

NEW YORK — October 2025 The New York Mets are making noise this awards season, with three of their stars — Pete Alonso, Francisco Lindor, and Juan…

OCTOBER NIGHTMARE RISING: The Mets are closing in on a $150 million, 3-time All-Star deal that could hand the Phillies their worst nightmare — a rivalry-defining power move that might shift the balance of the NL East and light up every headline in baseball…ll

The New York Mets could do something that no one sees coming.

OCTOBER HEIST ALERT: The Mets are plotting a $170 million master move — a contract so perfect it could snatch Alex Bregman right out of Boston’s hands, flip the AL script, and send shockwaves through every front office from Fenway to Flushing…ll

The Mets fell short in 2025 and they need to go after Alex Bregman if they don’t want to repeat their failure

OCTOBER RIVALRY ERUPTION: The Mets are sweating bullets as Kyle Schwarber’s $150 million deal talk sends Philly into overdrive — the slugger who’s torched New York time and time again might just lock in long-term, and Queens can already feel the heat rising…ll

Phillies Face Tough Decision on Kyle Schwarber’s Future As the Philadelphia Phillies prepare for a transformative offseason, all eyes are on Kyle Schwarber, whose recent MVP-caliber performance…

OCTOBER FIRESTORM: The Bronx is burning again — Yankees spark a trade frenzy chasing Brewers’ $15 million ace Freddy Peralta, a move that screams offseason blockbuster and could tilt the entire MLB power map before winter hits…ll

Explore Freddy Peralta’s potential trade to the Yankees and the impact on MLB’s offseason landscape.

OCTOBER RUMOR STORM: The Yankees are cooking again — eyeing an $8.5 million, two-time All-Star and three-time Gold Glove machine to fill Bellinger’s shoes, and insiders say this move could flip the AL East script overnight…ll

This would be a good signing to act as a bridge for prospects.