Breaking!! Former MVP turned down bigger offers to join Yankees, per MLB insider

The New York Yankees will enter the 2025 season with a quartet of former MVPs, including first baseman Paul Goldschmidt.

While the Yankees were seemingly in on some other options like Christian Walker and potentially Pete Alonso earlier in the offseason, they eventually settled on a shorter term deal with Goldschmidt.

And, according to Jon Heyman of The New York Post, the 37-year-old had bigger offers in front of him. Instead, he opted to join the Yankees.

“At least the Nats, Guardians and Diamondbacks were in for the ex-MVP, and word is, he turned down bigger offers. He and Carlos Santana, who signed a day later for 500K less back with his old Cleveland team, made the most financial sense (ultimately, they deemed Christian Walker and Pete Alonso too much loot),” Heyman wrote.

The Yankees agreed to a one-year deal worth $12.5 million to bring Goldschmidt to the The Bronx. Though he’s coming off a down season, he had a resurgent second half in which he posted a .799 OPS.

Whether it was the right move to go after Goldschmidt over Santana will be something of debate during the 2025 season, but this does give the Yankees a chance to platoon Goldschmidt and promising 25-year-old Ben Rice at first base.

While Rice struggled immensely against left-handed pitchers during his first season in the big leagues, Goldschmidt posted a strong .839 OPS against southpaws.

The Yankees offense is going to look very different from the one that returned to the World Series for the first time in 15 years, and they’re hoping to get the type of player Goldschmidt was during the second half of his down season.

MORE MLB: Yankees’ two-time All-Star predicted to sign $21M deal with Tigers

Related Posts

BLOCKBUSTER ALERT: The Mets pull off a jaw-dropping move, landing Diamondbacks’ Ketel Marte in a trade that could reshape the roster overnight. Front office sources hint this deal is just the start of a season-defining shake-up, with strategy and chemistry hanging in the balance. Every pitch, every lineup decision now carries the weight of a new era, and the Mets’ future is on the line..ll

The New York Mets are expected to be big players this offseason, but what blockbuster trade could they pull off to win the “hot stove” season?

CLASH OF STYLES: Pete Alonso and Alex Bregman couldn’t be more opposite fits for the Mets if they tried—one a raw power force, the other a calculated superstar with precision in every play. The team faces a dilemma on how to blend these extremes without breaking chemistry, and insiders warn the next moves could spark tension in the clubhouse. Every decision matters as the Mets try to balance firepower and finesse..ll

Aside from Kyle Tucker, Pete Alonso and Alex Bregman will be looked at as the 1A and 1B of position players on the market. While Alonso (or a replacement first

MET LIFE IN CHAOS: David Stearns is facing a Monday morning storm as fans brace for three shocking changes that could shake the Mets to their core. Rumors of trades, lineup shake-ups, and front-office moves are swirling, and insiders warn these decisions won’t be easy to swallow. Every choice could spark outrage, redefine the season, and test loyalty like never before..ll

David Stearns’ first and second offseasons with the New York Mets had a lot of the same types of moves. He took chances on pitchers coming off of bad seasons wi

NEW YORK ON EDGE: Don Mattingly rumors swirl like wildfire as the Mets face questions about leadership and direction in 2026. Every whisper fuels speculation, every decision could ignite chaos, and the city braces for a legend to step back into the spotlight. If Mattingly arrives, nothing will be the same, and the Bronx—and Queens—will be watching every move..ll

With the 2025 MLB season coming to a close, speculation is rising about the future of Don Mattingly, the former Yankees legend and recent Toronto Blue Jays…

COLE ON A MISSION: Gerrit Cole vows to evolve and take full command, promising to do whatever it takes to drag the struggling Yankees back to glory. Every pitch, every game, every decision will be under his fire as he aims to reignite a fallen dynasty. The Bronx is watching, the pressure is immense, and one superstar’s will could define the fate of the season..ll

Amid mounting pressure and growing concerns over the New York Yankees’ diminishing performance, ace pitcher Gerrit Cole has vowed to make the necessary changes to help revitalize…

YANKS TURMOIL: Aaron Boone’s future hangs by a thread as whispers of Don Mattingly returning ignite speculation—insiders hint the timing could be perfect, and the front office might be ready for a shock move. Every decision now could reshape the team’s strategy, while uncertainty looms over the Bronx like never before. The next weeks may decide whether Boone stays or Mattingly finally steps in to reclaim the dugout..ll

In a shocking turn of events for New York Yankees fans, reports are emerging that manager Aaron Boone could be on the verge of being fired, while…