BREAKING: Yankees, Tommy Kahnle could reunite again after reliever’s World Series meltdown

The Yankees have acquired Tommy Kahnle on three different occasions. Could there be a fourth time for the right-hander in The Bronx?

There is interest from both sides on a potential reunion for Kahnle, who had a strong season with the Yankees and pitched fairly well in the playoffs until an ugly final outing that helped cost the Yankees in their season-ending loss to the Dodgers in Game 5 of the World Series, when Kahnle was called upon to protect a one-run lead in the eighth inning and allowed all three batters he faced to reach base.

Afterward, Kahnle expressed a desire to stay with the team that first drafted him in 2010, traded for him in 2017 and signed him as a free agent following the 2022 season.

Yankees, Tommy Kahnle could reunite again after reliever’s World Series meltdown
Tommy Kahnle pitches during the World Series for the Yankees. Jason Szenes / New York Post

Kahnle was part of a relief corps that was at times dominant, while lacking in big names. He’s one of three key members of the pen on the open market, along with Clay Holmes and lefty Tim Hill.

Holmes seems likely to land elsewhere and, as The Post’s Joel Sherman reported, has drawn interest as a starting pitcher.

Hill, claimed off waivers by the Yankees after the White Sox released him in July, emerged as a much-needed left-handed weapon after other options like Victor Gonzalez failed.

Hill, who turns 35 in February, is also expected to have a healthy market and there are more than a handful of teams interested in Kahnle.

For the Yankees, they’re looking at a pen potentially anchored by Luke Weaver after he proved to be a capable closer, as well as other reclamation projects that remain on the roster like Ian Hamilton and Jake Cousins.

Yankees, Tommy Kahnle could reunite again after reliever’s World Series meltdown
Tommy Kahnle reacts during Game 1 of the World Series. Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post

Mark Leiter Jr. will be back despite an inconsistent few months in The Bronx after arriving in a trade from the Cubs. Scott Effross is another trade deadline acquisition from Chicago — in 2022 — who hasn’t regained his form after Tommy John surgery two years ago.

Kahnle is comfortable with the Yankees, who clearly like the reliever, who’s been nagged by injuries through much of his career.

Although he’s put up solid numbers, Kahnle hasn’t pitched more than the 42 ²/₃ regular-season innings he put up this past season since 2019. He’s missed time each of the past two years with right shoulder inflammation.

“I’ve been drafted here and brought back twice,” Kahnle said after the final game. “I love being a Yankee. I’d love to finish my career here.”

Prior to his Game 5 letdown, Kahnle hadn’t allowed a run in 8 ²/₃ postseason innings.

Unlike the starting pitching market, which has moved quickly — with notable deals handed out to Blake Snell, Frankie Montas and Matt Boyd — there haven’t been any multiyear contracts for relief pitchers so far this offseason.

Related Posts

New Giants reliever shares emotional reaction to unexpected trade from Mets

A Mets pitcher learns mid-game he’s been traded to the Giants, reacting emotionally as cameras capture the moment.

Mets could be ‘most aggressive’ team for trades. Here’s their plan

The 2025 trade deadline is Thursday, July 31.

Francisco Lindor Has High Praise for Mets’ Newly Acquired Bullpen Arm

Tyler Rogers is ready to bring his unique delivery to the Big Apple.

Grading the NY Mets trade with the Cardinals for Ryan Helsley

According to Jon Heyman of the NY Post, the New York Mets have acquired right-handed reliever Ryan Helsley from the St. Louis Cardinals. Heading to St. Louis ar

Yankees’ Anthony Volpe gets mercilessly clowned after 16th error of 2025 season

Anthony Volpe draws the ire of Yankees fans yet again after committing yet another error — his 16th of the 2025 season.

This Yankees-Dylan Cease trade package could close the deal based on Padres intel

The New York Yankees have exactly what the San Diego Padres are looking for in exchange for Dylan Cease or Robert Suárez at the MLB trade deadline.