Manchester United face a crucial few weeks ahead of the January transfer window, as several key players approach the final months of their contracts. Among the biggest names whose futures remain uncertain are Casemiro and Harry Maguire, two experienced figures who have played pivotal roles for Rúben Amorim this season.

Both veterans are set to be out of contract at the end of the campaign, meaning foreign clubs can begin negotiations from January. United now have a decision to make—whether to reward loyalty and experience with extensions, or move on and invest in younger options.

Casemiro’s revival under Amorim

Fabrizio Romano Reveals Manchester United’s Contract Decision on Casemiro and Harry Maguire Amid Salary Concerns

Casemiro’s first season at Old Trafford was largely seen as a success, but his form dipped last term, leading to questions about his long-term role. However, under Amorim, the Brazilian has rediscovered much of the composure and influence that made him one of the world’s best midfielders at Real Madrid.

Thanks to tactical adjustments that give him more protection and freedom to dictate play, Casemiro has once again become the heartbeat of United’s midfield. His leadership and experience have helped steady a team that has struggled for consistency in recent years.

Despite that resurgence, his contract situation presents a major dilemma for the club. At 33 years old, Casemiro’s wages are among the highest at Old Trafford—figures that could make an extension complicated.

Speaking on his YouTube channel, Fabrizio Romano provided crucial insight into how the situation stands. “Casemiro is a crucial player, in this moment, for Manchester United,” said the Italian journalist. “Credit to Casemiro, because when there is a lot of criticism and a difficult atmosphere at the club, it’s not easy to turn things around. But he did it. He worked hard and became, once again, a vital player for this manager.”

Romano, however, added that the midfielder’s current wages are “way too high” for the club to offer a simple renewal. “There will be a conversation about his contract,” he explained. “Amorim would love to keep Casemiro, but everything depends on the salary discussions.”

Maguire’s steady return to form

Fabrizio Romano Reveals Manchester United’s Contract Decision on Casemiro and Harry Maguire Amid Salary Concerns

While Casemiro has been key in midfield, Harry Maguire has also experienced a quiet resurgence in defense. Once a regular target of criticism, the English centre-back has found renewed confidence under Amorim’s system.

The Portuguese coach has deployed Maguire effectively in key fixtures, often using him in a back three alongside Matthijs de Ligt and Leny Yoro. Maguire’s physical presence and aerial strength remain assets in the Premier League, even if his mobility is sometimes questioned.

However, at 32, he too is nearing the end of his contract. United extended his deal for an additional year last season, but that only delayed the inevitable decision that now lies ahead.

Romano confirmed that Maguire’s future will be reviewed under the same conditions as Casemiro’s. “For Maguire, it’s the same situation,” he said. “He could stay if he agrees to new terms. Otherwise, he could leave on a free transfer.”

The financial factor and United’s long-term vision

The key issue for both players appears to be financial. Amorim values their experience and leadership, but the club’s wage structure has shifted since Jason Wilcox took over as technical director. United are now prioritizing sustainable contracts that reward performance and align with the new long-term strategy under Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s INEOS leadership.

Casemiro’s current deal, which places him among the top earners in the squad, doesn’t fit neatly into that model. Similarly, Maguire would likely need to take a pay cut to continue at Old Trafford.

Romano also noted that Casemiro continues to attract strong interest from Saudi Arabian clubs, who remain eager to sign him in 2025. “Casemiro has always received many proposals, especially from the Middle East,” said Romano. “But right now, he’s focused on United and wants to help the team. What happens next depends on the financial discussions.”

What comes next for Amorim’s squad

If United cannot agree reduced deals with either player, Amorim could turn to younger options within the squad. Academy products Ayden Heaven and Tyler Fredricson are both seen as potential long-term replacements for Maguire, while Leny Yoro and Matthijs de Ligt are already expected to form the defensive core for years to come.

Casemiro’s position, however, is harder to fill. Despite his age and occasional inconsistency, the Brazilian remains unmatched in terms of tactical awareness and leadership. Replacing him would likely require significant investment in the transfer market.

The coming months will test Manchester United’s commitment to their new vision. While Rúben Amorim wants to retain the experience of players like Casemiro and Maguire, the club’s evolving financial policy could make that difficult.

Ultimately, both players have shown their worth this season, proving they can still perform at the highest level. But as Romano reported, any extensions will depend on whether they’re willing to adapt to the club’s new wage structure—something that could define the next phase of Amorim’s rebuild at Old Trafford.