Orchard Park, New York – 3/11/2025

The Buffalo Bills’ 28-21 victory over the Kansas City Chiefs in Week 9 should have been a high-level clash remembered for the chess match between Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes. Yet, just hours after the final whistle, NFL social media exploded with a fierce wave of controversy – as thousands of fans claimed referee Shawn Hochuli and his crew made “non-transparent” decisions that altered the game’s outcome.

The focal incident occurred in the third quarter, when Mahomes was flagged for “intentional grounding” despite slow-motion replay showing his pass clearly tipped by a Bills defender’s hand before hitting the ground. Head coach Andy Reid immediately wanted to challenge, but the referee announced the play was “not reviewable.” The call halted the Chiefs’ drive, costing them a chance to cut the score.

Gene Steratore has never seen something like this in his career:

Intentional grounding was called on Patrick Mahomes here, but the referees failed to see that the ball was tipped at the line of scrimmage. Andy Reid attempted to challenge the ruling on the field, only to be told… pic.twitter.com/NWeWynyoRG

— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) November 2, 2025

Right after the game, on platforms X (Twitter) and Reddit, the phrase “Bills vs Chiefs rigged” quickly climbed to the top trends. Thousands of fans argued that moment “killed” Kansas City’s comeback hopes. And it wasn’t just fans speaking out — Chiefs Hall of Fame tight end legend Tony Gonzalez also expressed fury.

On CBS’s “NFL Prime Night,” Gonzalez said bluntly: “I can’t understand it. The tape clearly shows the ball tipped a Bills defender’s hand. How can that be called intentional grounding? The NFL needs to review Shawn Hochuli’s officiating crew. This isn’t just a mistake — it changed the outcome of the entire game.”

The former star also pointed to the Chiefs often being caught in unfavorable controversies: “When the Chiefs win, people say we ‘buy the refs.’ But when we lose because of bizarre calls, no one stands up for us. Where’s the fairness for Kansas City?”

The NFL has not yet issued an official response, but according to ESPN, the league’s officiating committee is reviewing the full game footage. Meanwhile, CBS rules experts assessed that the non-reviewable decision “may stem from a rule loophole, not bias.”

Though the result cannot be changed, the aftermath remains scorching. A clip compiling the entire controversial play has garnered over 5 million views in just 12 hours, and the hashtag #InvestigateHochuli is spreading across the NFL fan community — proof that for fans, the story of fairness on the field is far from over.