Yankees’ aggressive back-up plan if Juan Soto doesn’t re-sign is ‘floating around’

Right fielder Juan Soto is the free agent prize that seemingly will launch this quiet free agency period because teams that miss out will pivot to Plan Bs, where payroll can be reallocated to other stars.

For the New York Yankees, who met with Soto on Nov. 18, that means an aggressive back-up plan that will fill many of their holes. USA TODAY Sports’ Bob Nightengale revealed the expensive post-Soto fix Monday:

If the New York Yankees don’t re-sign Juan Soto, one back-up plan floating around is signing free-agent first baseman Christian Walker, sign either Willy Adames or Alex Bregman to play third, shift Jazz Chisholm to second base, trade for Cubs center fielder Cody Bellinger, and then use the extra money to sign Burnes, Fried or Snell.

RESTORING THE GLORY

That seems like a Plan B on overdrive, and it would mean owner Hal Steinbrenner taking on a lot more immediate salary at a time when he said a $300 million payroll was too high, though it would theoretically come with flexibility past Year 6 or 7 of Soto’s deal. These moves would fill major needs, and an argument could be made that they would make the Yankees a better all-around team — if Soto weren’t the only player they added (which would not be the case).

Let’s use The Athletic’s contract projections:

Right field: Juan Soto (13 years, $611 million; $47 million average annual value)

First base: Christian Walker (two years, $44 million; $22 million AAV)

Third base: Willy Adames (six years, $150 million; $25 million AAV)

Third base: Alex Bregman (seven years, $189 million; $27 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Corbin Burnes (seven years, $217 million; $31 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Max Fried (five years, $140 million; $28 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Blake Snell (four years, $110 million; $27.5 million AAV)

Center field: Cody Bellinger (one year, $27.5 million; player option for $25 million in 2025)

NJ Advance Media’s Bob Klapisch wrote recently that the Yankees could pivot to a spread-the-money back-up plan, with several of the big names Klapisch included:

So prepare to say hello to the Plan B newcomers Steinbrenner and GM Brian Cashman are quietly considering: ace Corbin Burnes, third baseman Alex Bregman, first baseman Christian Walker and right fielder Anthony Santander.

For what it’s worth, 12 of 18 executives polled by ESPN in a story published last week said that they’d expect Soto to return to the Yankees.

On Sunday, ESPN’s Buster Olney reported that initial offers will be made to Soto this week.

With the Yankees in 2024, Soto enjoyed the best 162-game season of his career. In 157 games, he slashed .288/.419/.569 and posted career highs in hits (156), run scored (128), home runs (41) and OPS+ (178).

Related Posts

SEMIEN SPEAKS: Marcus Semien breaks his silence following a “surprising” trade from the Rangers to the Mets, sending shockwaves through MLB. Sources hint at mixed emotions as he adjusts to his new team and city, fueling speculation about his impact. Every word and action is being analyzed as fans and insiders wonder how he’ll fit into the Mets’ lineup. Whatever unfolds, Semien’s arrival has instantly turned heads in New York..ll

New York Mets 2B Marcus Semien finally broke his silence following his recent acquisition by the team via trade with the Texas Rangers.

METS TRADE ALERT: Tatsuya Imai gives the NY Mets yet another reason to consider trading Kodai Senga, sending shockwaves through the pitching rotation. Sources hint at performance concerns and strategic planning that could reshape the rotation entirely. Every rumor fuels speculation as analysts debate Senga’s future in New York. Whatever unfolds, the Mets’ decision-making is under a magnifying glass..ll

The common rule of thumb for Japanese stars coming over stateside is that their preferences are to land on the West Coast and with a team that already employs o

METS SHAKEUP: After the Brandon Nimmo blindside, speculation is heating up on which five NY Mets players could be traded next. Sources hint at high-stakes decisions and strategic moves that could reshape the roster entirely. Every rumor adds tension as analysts and insiders debate who might be on the move. Whatever unfolds, the Mets’ front office is keeping the league on edge..ll

If you believed the New York Mets were really going to trade Brandon Nimmo, kudos to you. You’re built differently. The ongoing Nimmo rumors felt like the usual

METS BETRAYAL: The Mets’ home run king is predicted to turn his back on New York for a staggering $210 million payday, sending shockwaves through the fanbase. Sources hint at secret negotiations and high-stakes drama behind the scenes, fueling speculation across MLB. Every rumor adds tension as analysts debate the future of the franchise without their superstar. Whatever unfolds, the Big Apple is bracing for a potential seismic shift..ll

He set the franchise home run record this year, but this Mets star is now predicted to follow the money to hated division rival.

GRISHAM SHOCKER: Trent Grisham stuns MLB by turning down massive $120 million long-term offers to join the Yankees. Sources hint at loyalty and family values driving his unexpected decision, sending shockwaves through the league. Every analyst is buzzing as speculation mounts over how the Pinstripes will utilize their new star. Whatever unfolds, the Yankees’ latest move has everyone talking..ll

Article

YANKEES FUTURE SHOCK: Hal Steinbrenner is reportedly considering leadership changes as speculation swirls around Brian Cashman’s role. Sources hint at high-stakes decisions that could redefine the Bronx Bombers’ direction and strategy. Every rumor fuels debate on what the front office might do next, keeping the league and insiders on edge. Whatever unfolds, all eyes are on New York as this saga heats up..ll

🔎 Why There’s Talk About Replacing Cashman After a disappointing 2025 season — missing the playoffs — Steinbrenner admitted the club is evaluating “everything”: from coaching and…