Yankees’ aggressive back-up plan if Juan Soto doesn’t re-sign is ‘floating around’

Right fielder Juan Soto is the free agent prize that seemingly will launch this quiet free agency period because teams that miss out will pivot to Plan Bs, where payroll can be reallocated to other stars.

For the New York Yankees, who met with Soto on Nov. 18, that means an aggressive back-up plan that will fill many of their holes. USA TODAY Sports’ Bob Nightengale revealed the expensive post-Soto fix Monday:

If the New York Yankees don’t re-sign Juan Soto, one back-up plan floating around is signing free-agent first baseman Christian Walker, sign either Willy Adames or Alex Bregman to play third, shift Jazz Chisholm to second base, trade for Cubs center fielder Cody Bellinger, and then use the extra money to sign Burnes, Fried or Snell.

RESTORING THE GLORY

That seems like a Plan B on overdrive, and it would mean owner Hal Steinbrenner taking on a lot more immediate salary at a time when he said a $300 million payroll was too high, though it would theoretically come with flexibility past Year 6 or 7 of Soto’s deal. These moves would fill major needs, and an argument could be made that they would make the Yankees a better all-around team — if Soto weren’t the only player they added (which would not be the case).

Let’s use The Athletic’s contract projections:

Right field: Juan Soto (13 years, $611 million; $47 million average annual value)

First base: Christian Walker (two years, $44 million; $22 million AAV)

Third base: Willy Adames (six years, $150 million; $25 million AAV)

Third base: Alex Bregman (seven years, $189 million; $27 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Corbin Burnes (seven years, $217 million; $31 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Max Fried (five years, $140 million; $28 million AAV)

Starting pitcher: Blake Snell (four years, $110 million; $27.5 million AAV)

Center field: Cody Bellinger (one year, $27.5 million; player option for $25 million in 2025)

NJ Advance Media’s Bob Klapisch wrote recently that the Yankees could pivot to a spread-the-money back-up plan, with several of the big names Klapisch included:

So prepare to say hello to the Plan B newcomers Steinbrenner and GM Brian Cashman are quietly considering: ace Corbin Burnes, third baseman Alex Bregman, first baseman Christian Walker and right fielder Anthony Santander.

For what it’s worth, 12 of 18 executives polled by ESPN in a story published last week said that they’d expect Soto to return to the Yankees.

On Sunday, ESPN’s Buster Olney reported that initial offers will be made to Soto this week.

With the Yankees in 2024, Soto enjoyed the best 162-game season of his career. In 157 games, he slashed .288/.419/.569 and posted career highs in hits (156), run scored (128), home runs (41) and OPS+ (178).

Related Posts

MET CLUBHOUSE EXPLOSION: A shockwave ripped through Queens as Mets executives openly discussed the real possibility of Pete Alonso leaving the team. Immediately after, Francisco Lindor fired off a jaw-dropping 15-word message that stunned the baseball world. Internal sources reveal the words were neither vague nor diplomatic, but direct and emotional, igniting speculation and heated debate. And now, the burning question: is Lindor hinting at a future without the “Polar Bear”… or fighting to keep him..ll

In a stunning turn of events that has rocked the baseball world, Francisco Lindor has issued a shocking 15-word statement following the release of the latest information on Pete Alonso‘s departure from the New York Mets. This development has sent shockwaves through the sports community, prompting widespread speculation and analysis. As fans and analysts alike grapple with the implications, the shocking statement from Lindor adds a layer of intrigue to an already tumultuous situation. The departure of Pete Alonso, a key player for the Mets, has been a topic of intense discussion, and Lindor’s response has only heightened the drama. In this article, we delve deep into the details, providing a comprehensive overview of the events, the statement, and what it means for the future of the team.

MET CLUBHOUSE ALERT: It has been revealed that the New York Mets may have experienced some clubhouse issues during the 2025 season. Internal sources indicate that tension and disagreements affected the team’s morale. Today, a key reminder about what makes a good team great and a bad team weak has been shared. And now, the big question: what will the Mets learn from this season to come back stronger..ll

The Mets reportedly had some clubhouse rifts over the course of the 2025 season. Plus, some buzz on Kyle Schwarber and Kyle Tucker

ALONSO SHOCKER: “I’m going to pack up and go home right now!” Pete Alonso shocked MLB by bluntly declaring he would rather retire than play for the New York Yankees. Internal sources reveal this is an unprecedentedly strong message directed at the Mets’ biggest rival. Baseball analysts continue debating the mental and strategic impact of this statement. And now, the burning question: will Alonso truly stick to his stance, or is this merely a strategic move..ll

Few statements in recent MLB history have sent shockwaves through the baseball world quite like Pete Alonso’s explosive declaration that he would rather “pack up and go home” or even “retire” than ever play for the New York Yankees. In a single blunt moment, the New York Mets’ powerhouse first baseman ignited debates across the league, stunned fans on both sides of the city rivalry, and delivered what many analysts view as one of the strongest public messages ever directed at the Mets’ most iconic opponent.

YANKS’ HIGH-STAKES DILEMMA: The Yankees face a decision that could shape the next decade: lock up Ben Rice now with a massive pre-arbitration deal, or risk paying a jaw-dropping premium later. Sources inside the front office reveal tension is at a peak as Rice’s slugging power keeps escalating, making patience increasingly costly. Advisors warn that waiting could either mean losing a homegrown star to a rival or committing to a $300+ million contract down the line. And now, the league watches closely as New York teeters between fiscal discipline and securing a potential generational talent..ll

THE BRONX, NY — The New York Yankees are facing a crucial financial and philosophical crossroads centered on homegrown slugger Ben Rice. After a breakout 2025 season that saw…

SHOCKING REVELATION: “I can’t keep this secret any longer – please help my son,” Aaron Judge’s mother exclaimed, revealing the heartbreaking truth behind his decision to retire after the 2025 season. After years of silence and speculation, Judge finally spoke up and shared everything. Internal sources reveal that this revelation has left coaches and the baseball world stunned. And now, the entire world is left wondering: what truly drove a superstar to make such a sudden decision..ll

“I can’t keep this secret any longer – please help my son.” These words, spoken by Aaron Judge’s mother, have sent shockwaves throughout the baseball world, revealing…

JETER WARNING: Derek Jeter has sent a powerful message to the Yankees regarding a potential trade of Jasson Dominguez, sending shockwaves through the baseball world. Internal sources reveal Jeter stressed, “think twice before you let that kind of talent walk.” His words immediately put the coaching staff and team management on alert. And now, the question remains: will the Yankees dare to let Dominguez go..ll

Article