During the 2025 season, the New York Mets recognized a need to strengthen their defense, particularly in the outfield. One noticeable concern has been Juan Soto, the team’s star outfielder, whose defensive metrics at right field have been below average. According to advanced stats like Outs Above Average (OAA) and Fielding Run Value (FRV), Soto ranks in the lower percentile, indicating a decline in his defensive performance.

To address this, some experts have suggested moving Soto to first base, where he could minimize defensive mistakes while continuing to focus on his offensive contributions. This strategy mirrors what was done with Bryce Harper, who shifted from the outfield to first base to preserve his health and enhance performance.

However, the transition raises questions about Soto’s offensive role. In 2025, he hit 43 home runs and drove in 105 RBIs, posting a .921 OPS, demonstrating consistent offensive production. Moving him to first base could reduce defensive pressure but may also impact his playing time and the team’s offensive strategy.

Another factor to consider is potential roster changes. If Pete Alonso were to leave in the upcoming offseason, moving Soto to first base could fill the vacancy, simultaneously improving defense while maintaining the Mets’ offensive firepower.

In conclusion, shifting Juan Soto to first base is a strategy worth considering for the Mets to bolster their defense next season. However, the decision requires careful evaluation to balance defensive gains with potential impacts on the team’s offensive strategy.