Getty

The New York Mets didn’t just miss the playoffs in 2025—they missed an identity. After another lost season defined by erratic pitching and uneven roster construction, Bleacher Report believes the franchise finally has a chance to reset. Their proposed solution: make Dylan Cease the centerpiece of Steve Cohen’s next big spending spree.

Why Dylan Cease and the Mets Make Sense

Bleacher Report ranked the Mets as the No. 1 “perfect fit” for Cease this offseason, pointing to their enormous payroll flexibility and desperate need for stability atop the rotation. Even after a 4.55 ERA and 8–12 record this year, Cease remains one of baseball’s most durable and high-octane arms. His 11.5 strikeouts per nine innings and fifth straight season with at least 3.0 FanGraphs WAR tell a story of consistency that box-score stats don’t fully capture.

The underlying data backs it up. Cease’s FIP, xERA, and xwOBA all suggest his 2025 struggles were more about bad luck than regression. His velocity stayed intact, his slider still ranks among the best in baseball, and his swing-and-miss metrics mirror those from his Cy Young-caliber 2022 campaign. Analysts have already drawn comparisons between Cease’s current free-agent outlook and Aaron Nola’s two winters ago—when Nola parlayed an uneven platform season into a $172 million deal from the Phillies.

For the Mets, that’s exactly the kind of risk they can afford to take. Kodai Senga can’t be their lone frontline starter, and behind him lies a shaky mix of David Peterson, Sean Manaea, and untested youngster Nolan McLean. With their rotation ranking in the bottom third of the league in quality starts, adding Cease would instantly provide legitimacy and leadership to a staff in disarray.

Cohen’s Checkbook Could Change Everything

According to B/R, the Mets’ 2026 payroll before arbitration and player options sits under $200 million—far below the $320 million threshold Steve Cohen crossed in each of the past three seasons. Even if Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz opt out, there’s still plenty of financial breathing room to make a bold move for a true ace.

Cohen has never shied away from spending big to fix glaring weaknesses. His attempts to pair Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer showed ambition, even if the experiment fell apart. Cease, however, offers something those veterans didn’t: youth, endurance, and long-term value. At 29, he could anchor the Mets through the rest of the decade, giving them a stable ace to build around.

Bleacher Report’s projection reads as both practical and poetic—a talented but unlucky pitcher meets a franchise built on excess and expectations. Cease’s raw stuff fits Citi Field’s dimensions, and his durability answers the club’s most pressing question: who takes the ball every fifth day?

While other teams, such as the Giants, Astros, and Padres, are expected to show interest, none combine the Mets’ combination of payroll power, rotation need, and fan impatience. Signing Cease wouldn’t just patch a hole; it would send a message that the “win now” mentality in Queens isn’t dead—it’s evolving.

After years of high spending with minimal payoff, New York finally has the chance to make a big move that makes baseball sense. If Bleacher Report is right, Dylan Cease isn’t just a perfect fit. He’s the missing piece the Mets have been searching for.

Alvin Garcia Born in Puerto Rico, Alvin Garcia is a sports writer for Heavy.com who focuses on MLB. His work has appeared on FanSided, LWOS, NewsBreak, Athlon Sports, and Yardbarker, covering mostly MLB. More about Alvin Garcia