METS BLOCKBUSTER: The Mets are predicted to target Nolan Arenado in an offseason trade, sparking debate about roster shakeups, financial gambles, and whether adding a superstar third baseman could finally push New York back into contention…ll

1 Cardinals prospect the NY Mets should demand in a Nolan Arenado trade

The New York Mets know they need to retool their roster this winter after missing the playoffs.

One of the areas that needs to be improved is fielding, and the Mets have a variety of ways they can go about upgrading defensively. However, Zachary D. Rymer of Bleacher Report believes one of the best ways to do that is by trading for Nolan Arenado from the St. Louis Cardinals.

“There’s a lot the Mets need to address this winter, and Jon Heyman of the New York Post isn’t wrong to see the defense as a potentially overlooked priority,” Rymer wrote. “Per their minus-12 Outs Above Average, they had a bottom-10 defense this season. This alone should give the Mets some level of interest in Arenado. He’s a 10-time Gold Glover who remains a strong defender at third base, posting plus-3 OAA this season.”

Here is the full breakdown of the predicted hypothetical trade:

New York Mets acquire: 3B Nolan Arenado St. Louis Cardinals acquire: LHP Sean Manaea, RHP Jonathan Pintaro (Mets No. 17 prospect), Cash considerations

Adding Arenado’s defense would be a huge upgrade for the Mets. His bat isn’t what it used to be, but his glove can certainly make up for that at the hot corner. The Cardinals would also get Arenado’s contract off of their books, but they would have to, at least temporarily, take on Manaea’s contract.

“The Cardinals could then look to flip Manaea, either during the winter or in 2026 after (hopefully) he bounces back from an injury-marred year in which he had a 5.64 ERA,” wrote Rymer. “Pintaro would be a deal-sweetener of sorts for the Cardinals. He’s a mid-level prospect at best, but he has three above-average pitches, and he at least profiles as a specialist after holding righty batters to a .597 OPS in the minors this year.”

This trade would make sense for both teams as the Cardinals can start their rebuild after being stuck in the middle this season while the Mets get a major boost defensively in hopes of making a deep playoff run next year.

 

Related Posts

QUEENS SHAKE-UP: Mets Urged to Lock In Edwin Díaz With a Bold Re-Sign Push, While Buzz Builds Around Three Electrifying Targets Who Could Flip the Entire Roster Script..ll

This offseason, the New York Mets face several tall tasks, including a complete overhaul of the pitching staff that failed them down the stretch in 2025. This w

LOCKER ROOM RUMBLE: Adam Ottavino Drops Stinging Truth Bomb on the Mets, Calling Out Cracks That Can’t Be Ignored, A Message Carlos Mendoza Can’t Afford to Brush Off..ll

When a former player unloads on his old manager, the easiest reaction is to roll your eyes. It’s a tale as old as baseball: a veteran pushed out of the circle o

OCTOBER SHOWDOWN: Mets Poised for Jaw-Dropping Move as $75M All-Star Hits the Trade Bubble, Whispers Point to a Surging AL East Power Ready to Strike..ll

The New York Mets signed Kodai Senga before the 2023 season. His five-year, $75 million deal looked like a bargain when he was named an All-Star as…

MLB FREE AGENCY ALERT: Why the Phillies Could Poach Pete Alonso From the Mets, With Potential Moves That Could Shake the League and Reshape the NL East Power Dynamics…ll

Pete Alonso is a free agent target for the Phillies this winter.

MLB TRADE ALERT: Yankees Receive Crucial Update on $325 Million Superstar Shortstop’s Contract, Sparking Speculation About Potential Moves and the Team’s Offseason Strategy…ll

The New York Yankees have received a significant contract upgrade on a superstar infielder that is generating trade speculation.

MLB OFFSEASON ALERT: Yankees Make $4.5 Million Early Decision With Fan-Favorite, Sending Shockwaves Through the Locker Room and Raising Questions About Team Direction…ll

The Yankees are locking up a fan favorite early into the offseason.