The football world is buzzing this evening after former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher finally gave his verdict on the highly controversial penalty incident involving Alexander Isak during Chelsea’s 2-1 win over Liverpool — a moment that left Arne Slot fuming on the touchline and fans demanding answers.

The incident occurred midway through the second half when Isak appeared to go down under minimal contact from Trent Alexander-Arnold inside the box. Chelsea players immediately appealed, and VAR called for a review — but to the disbelief of many, the referee waved play on.

Speaking on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch, Gallagher weighed in on the heated debate, finally breaking the silence on what has become one of the most talked-about moments of the match.

“I’ve reviewed the footage several times,” Gallagher said. “There was contact, yes, but not enough to warrant a penalty. Isak exaggerated the fall, and the referee made the right call by not awarding it. VAR was correct not to intervene because it wasn’t a clear and obvious error.”

THE INCIDENT THAT IGNITED ANFIELD’S OUTRAGE

Moments after the game, Liverpool boss Arne Slot was visibly furious, describing the decision as “shocking” and “inconsistent with how VAR operates.” He demanded an explanation from the officials, claiming similar incidents had gone against Liverpool all season.

“It’s frustrating,” Slot said post-match. “We’ve had decisions go against us before, and this one was another example. If that was on the other end, it would’ve been given without hesitation.”

Fans echoed Slot’s frustration, flooding social media with clips of the challenge, pointing out that less contact has resulted in penalties for other teams this season.

A FINAL AGREEMENT REACHED

Following the outcry, sources close to the FA confirmed that internal discussions were held between refereeing officials to review the incident. Gallagher’s statement has now been accepted as the final stance — confirming that the on-field decision will stand with no further action.

While some pundits praised the officials for staying consistent, others insist Liverpool were “robbed again,” with calls growing for VAR reforms and greater transparency in Premier League officiating.

For now, the dust has settled — but the frustration remains. Liverpool fans are still demanding accountability, insisting this decision could have changed the course of the match.

A night of drama, fury, and yet another VAR controversy that refuses to go away.