Live from Old Trafford, the post-match debate has taken a shocking turn — and this time, it’s not about the scoreline, but about one man. Manchester United legend Rio Ferdinand has brutally criticized Casemiro, claiming the Brazilian midfielder is now a liability rather than a leader in Ruben Amorim’s system.

Ferdinand didn’t hold back as he dissected the performance that left fans divided despite the victory.

He said:

“Starting him today for Manchester United was a terrible decision, and it just shows Amorim still has a lot to learn. He’s slow on the ball, lacks composure, and brings zero creativity to the team. Everyone saw his costly mistakes — he offered absolutely nothing! If Amorim wants to keep his job, he needs to stop starting him immediately before he drags the whole team down.”

Those words cut deep. Casemiro, once regarded as one of the finest defensive midfielders in the world, now finds himself under intense scrutiny from both pundits and supporters. His lack of pace, poor decision-making, and tendency to give away dangerous balls have turned him from a hero into one of the most criticized figures in United’s dressing room.

A Champion Turned Burden

When Casemiro arrived from Real Madrid, expectations were sky-high. The five-time Champions League winner was seen as the man who would bring steel, leadership, and world-class mentality to a struggling United midfield. But over the past year, that aura seems to have faded.

Under Amorim, his performances have been inconsistent at best — often looking out of rhythm with younger, more energetic teammates like Kobbie Mainoo. Critics believe his presence slows United’s transitions and breaks the fluidity the manager is trying to build.

“Casemiro looks lost in this new system,” one fan wrote on social media. “He’s a shadow of the warrior we once knew. It’s painful to watch.”

The Fans Are Losing Patience

After today’s match, thousands of United supporters flooded social media calling for the veteran to be benched — some even suggesting it’s time for him to move on. Others echoed Ferdinand’s frustration, insisting Amorim must be bold enough to trust youth over experience.

One furious fan posted:

“That’s why we’re always complaining when he’s on the pitch! I don’t know why he’s still at this club. He’s killing our momentum.”

What Next for Amorim and Casemiro?

With pressure mounting and fans growing restless, Amorim faces a tough decision. Will he drop one of his biggest names to restore balance and intensity, or keep faith in Casemiro hoping for a turnaround?

Whatever happens next, one thing is certain — the Casemiro debate is tearing United fans apart, and Ferdinand’s comments have only added fuel to the fire.