⚡COLE MYSTERY: Yankees ace Gerrit Cole is nowhere to be seen as fans panic over why he’s absent from New York’s 2025 playoff rotation, social feeds explode with speculation and hot takes, analysts scramble to explain the shocking omission while teammates react in stunned silence, now the burning question is… what’s really keeping Cole out of the postseason?.. ll

The New York Yankees are back in the postseason for the eighth time in nine seasons. And as the franchise eyes a second consecutive run to the World Series, it will be without a key contributor from 2024.Right-handed ace Gerrit Cole will be noticeably absent from the Yankees’ playoff roster in 2024, though his presence will be felt in the dugout. The 35-year-old’s last appearance on the mound came in Game 5 of the 2024 World Series, and his next won’t come until 2026 at the earliest.

Where is Cole? Here is what to know about New York’s former Cy Young winner and why he won’t be able to help his team in its pursuit of a record 28th World Series title.

Where is Gerrit Cole? Why Yankees ace is not in New York's 2025 playoff rotation image

Where is Gerrit Cole?

Cole is not on the Yankees’ 2025 playoff roster, as he underwent Tommy John surgery before the season.

After undergoing surgery in March, Cole was placed on the 60-day injured list, freeing up a roster spot. He did not play at all during the 2025 MLB season.

While Cole is not on the playoff roster, he has actively been around the team. As New York prepared for its wild-card series with the Boston Red Sox, Cole stood in as a baserunner.

Gerrit Cole is serving as a baserunner for the Yankees while they run infield drills pic.twitter.com/paxHY4E9Uh

https://www.sportingnews.com/us/mlb/new-york-yankees/news/gerrit-cole-yankees-ace-new-york-2025-playoff-rotation/57330ee7869830bad8ead1d3

 

Gerrit Cole injury update

Cole underwent season-ending Tommy John surgery on March 11.

In May, Cole said he is planning on a 14-month recovery period, which would pave the way for him to get back to pitching in 2026, barring any setbacks. Cole began a throwing program in August 2025, making 20 flat-ground throws.

When will Gerrit Cole return?

The 14-month timeline would mean Cole’s rehabilitation process is complete in May 2026.

With that in mind, Cole’s journey to return to the Yankees is more complex than outlining a timeline. While impossible to forecast completely, Cole’s return to pitch for New York could include rehab assignments in the minors and a measured ramp-up process.

The Yankees will likely provide a clearer timeline for Cole’s return in the lead-up to the 2026 season.

MORE: Aaron Judge vs. Cal Raleigh: The key stats you need to know in 2025 AL MVP debate

Yankees 2025 pitching rotation

In Cole’s absence, the Yankees’ rotation of starters is headlined by another recent free-agent acquisition in Max Fried.

Here is an outlook at their rotation:

Pitcher 2025 record 2025 ERA
1 Max Fried 19-5 2.86
2 Carlos Rodón 18-9 3.09
3 Cam Schlittler 4-3 2.96
4 Luis Gil 4-1 3.32

Related Posts

LOCK HIM NOW: Francisco Lindor stares down Steve Cohen with a chilling warning — “Don’t dream of winning a championship if you let Pete Alonso go,” freezing the clubhouse as whispers erupt that this confrontation could define the Mets’ entire future and push the limits of every player’s loyalty..ll

In the high-stakes world of professional baseball, moments of tension can shift the entire trajectory of a franchise. One such pivotal incident unfolded recently in the Mets clubhouse, where Francisco Lindor locked eyes with owner Steve Cohen and delivered a chilling warning: “Don’t dream of winning a championship if you let Pete Alonso go.” The air grew thick, and the clubhouse fell silent as whispers erupted, hinting that this confrontation might test the limits of loyalty and reshape the Mets‘ path to glory. This event isn’t just a fleeting argument; it’s a potential turning point that could echo through the annals of baseball history, challenging the delicate balance between player dedication and ownership decisions.

INSIDER ALERT: David Stearns “really wants” Pete Alonso to stay with the Mets, but the clock is ticking and the time for a multi-million dollar deal might not be right yet, leaving fans and insiders on edge as the future of one of baseball’s biggest stars hangs in the balance..ll

In the ever-evolving landscape of Major League Baseball (MLB), team dynamics and player contracts often take center stage. One such storyline that has captured the attention of New York Mets fans and analysts alike revolves around Pete Alonso, the powerhouse first baseman, and the organization’s general manager, David Stearns. Recent reports indicate that Stearns is eager to retain Alonso long-term, but the timing for a substantial multi-million dollar deal might not align just yet. This article delves deep into the nuances of this situation, exploring Alonso‘s contributions to the Mets, the strategic considerations behind Stearns‘ approach, and what the future might hold for this talented slugger.

SHOCKING REVELATION: “Look at the value I brought to the team…” Pete Alonso breaks his silence on live TV with a 10-word statement that leaves New York Mets fans stunned, sparking debates, viral clips, and nonstop chatter across the city as everyone tries to decode his bold message..ll

In the world of professional baseball, where every word from a star player can spark intense debate, Pete Alonso recently made headlines with a succinct yet powerful statement. Appearing on television, the New York Mets slugger uttered just ten words: “Look at the value I brought to the team.” This brief declaration left Mets fans stunned, igniting discussions about his contributions to the franchise. As a key figure in the Major League Baseball landscape, Pete Alonso has consistently demonstrated his worth through impressive stats and clutch performances. This article delves deep into the context of his statement, exploring his career trajectory, impact on the New York Mets, and the broader implications for baseball enthusiasts.

HEART-STOPPING CONFESSION: “I will fight my best if I have the chance to stay at the New York Mets,” Pete Alonso told his teammates, sparking an emotional avalanche in the locker room as even the toughest players couldn’t hold back tears, leaving everyone stunned by the raw passion and loyalty on display..ll

In the world of professional baseball, where Pete Alonso has carved out a reputation as a powerhouse hitter and a dedicated team player, moments of raw emotion can sometimes reveal the true depth of a player’s commitment. Recently, Pete Alonso, the star first baseman for the New York Mets, shared a deeply personal confession with his teammates that left the entire locker room in tears. “I will fight my best if I have the chance to stay at the New York Mets,” he confided, his words echoing through the room and stirring emotions that transcended the usual camaraderie of the clubhouse. This incident not only highlighted Pete Alonso‘s unwavering loyalty but also underscored the profound bond within the New York Mets organization, reminding fans and followers alike of the human side of baseball.

EXCLUSIVE: Aaron Boone BANISHES Stroman from Yankees following a violent clash that’s rocking the clubhouse, taking extreme measures after a fiery showdown with Marcus Stroman, and leaving everyone desperate to uncover the shocking reason behind this explosive banishment..ll

EXCLUSIVE: Aaron Boone Banishes Stroman from Yankees After Violent Clash

WHAT?! Stroman on the move already?! Yankees shake the league with a jaw-dropping trade, and the player arriving from Miami is even more shocking, threatening to flip the entire season upside down and leaving everyone scrambling to process who’s actually involved..ll

Yankees Trade Rumor ERUPTS: Marcus Stroman Reportedly on the Move in Shocking Deal Involving Marlins Star