The drama never stops at Anfield, and today it’s manager Arne Slot who has left fans furious with a decision that many are calling one of the boldest—and possibly most reckless—choices of his tenure so far.

Ahead of Liverpool’s crucial Premier League showdown, Slot confirmed that Alexander Isak, who delivered a jaw-dropping performance against Atletico Madrid in the Champions League, will not be guaranteed a place in today’s starting lineup.

Slot’s words were blunt and unapologetic:

“Just because he performed well in our last game against Atletico Madrid doesn’t guarantee him that he will start today. I already have my starter before he came.”

The comments have immediately set social media ablaze. Fans who watched Isak dominate Atletico with his pace, pressing, and goal threat cannot believe the striker may be benched for such an important match. For many, this feels like a repeat of past mistakes, where in-form players were overlooked in favor of Slot’s pre-set plans.

Supporters have accused the Dutch coach of being too rigid and unwilling to adapt to the moment. “If Isak doesn’t start after a game like that, what message does it send?” one angry fan posted on X (Twitter). Another wrote: “He’s our most dangerous forward right now. Bench him and we’re handing the game away before it even begins.”

Pundits, too, are questioning the decision. Analysts argue that Slot risks stifling the team’s attacking momentum just as Liverpool need it most. With Isak brimming with confidence, dropping him could affect not only his rhythm but also the morale of the squad.

Even worse, many fear this choice could backfire against a stubborn opponent like Everton, who know how to frustrate Liverpool in these fiery derby encounters. By sidelining their most in-form attacker, the Reds may be giving their rivals exactly the chance they need to capitalize.

The frustration is summed up in the words echoing across fan forums:

ANOTHER HUGE MISTAKE FROM ARNE SLOT—WHAT IS HE THINKING?

Liverpool are at a crossroads. With the Premier League title race heating up and the Champions League demanding consistency, fans are demanding clarity and results. If Slot’s gamble fails today, the pressure on him will only intensify—and questions about his judgment will grow louder.

One thing is clear: the Isak decision has already divided the fanbase, and kickoff hasn’t even arrived.